Home Insurance

How Much Is Homeowners Insurance in Idaho in 2026? Boise, Meridian, and the Real Average

Homeowners insurance in Idaho costs $1,759 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, per ValuePenguin, or $2,195 for a $400,000 dwelling, per NerdWallet. State Farm is cheapest at $1,054 a year, Boise runs $1,608 a year against $2,012 in Fenn, and rates rose more than 50 percent in five years.

On this page

Homeowners insurance in Idaho costs $1,759 a year on average in 2026 for a $350,000 dwelling policy, according to ValuePenguin, or about $147 a month. Other datasets put the same state average anywhere from $1,437 to $2,195 a year, because they price different houses with different methods. This post lays out what each dataset actually measures, what Idaho homeowners pay by city and carrier, and what moves your own premium.

The spread between sources is worth understanding before you shop. NerdWallet prices a $400,000 dwelling for a 40 year old homeowner with good credit. ValuePenguin prices a $350,000 dwelling for a 45 year old married man with no claims. Insurify uses real quotes for a $300,000 dwelling. A bigger house costs more to insure, so the $400,000 figures run higher by design. None of these numbers is wrong. They answer slightly different questions, and the honest way to read them is side by side.

How much is homeowners insurance in Idaho in 2026?

For a $350,000 dwelling with a $1,000 deductible, Idaho homeowners pay about $1,759 a year, or $147 a month, according to ValuePenguin. That is 27 percent below the national average of $2,395 a year for the same coverage in the same study. For a $400,000 dwelling, NerdWallet puts the Idaho average at $2,195 a year, or $183 a month, against a national average of $2,490.

Source Dwelling coverage Average per year Average per month
ValuePenguin (Aug 2026) $350,000 $1,759 $147
NerdWallet (Mar 2026) $400,000 $2,195 $183
Insurify (Aug 2026) $300,000 $1,740 $145
ValuePenguin national table (Sept 2026) $350,000 $1,437 $120
BrandComparisons (Apr 2026) $300,000 $2,240 $187

Two figures in that table need a note. ValuePenguin lists Idaho at $1,437 a year in its national state table and at $1,759 a year on its own Idaho page, both for $350,000 of dwelling coverage. The two pages price different sample homes, so the gap is a methodology difference, not a mistake in one of them. The Idaho page figure is the one built from Idaho ZIP codes and the Idaho sample home, so it is the better number to quote for Idaho.

One more figure puts the study averages in context. MonitorBankRates, compiling the most recent National Association of Insurance Commissioners data, reports that Idaho homeowners actually paid $884 a year on average, with a median of $1,088. That NAIC data covers 2021 policies at every coverage level, so it runs well below current quote averages and lags the market by years. Treat it as a floor from what people really paid, not as a price you can buy today.

Which companies offer the cheapest homeowners insurance in Idaho?

State Farm has the cheapest home insurance rates for most Idaho homes, at $1,054 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, according to ValuePenguin. Mutual of Enumclaw is cheapest for homes that would cost less than $350,000 to rebuild. Grange is also affordable at every dwelling level and earns ValuePenguin’s best overall rating for Idaho on coverage, service, and price combined.

Company Average per year Coverage priced Source
State Farm $1,054 $350,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026
Mutual of Enumclaw $736 $200,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026
State Farm $774 $200,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026
Grange $803 $200,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026
Travelers $838 $200,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026
American Family $1,049 $200,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026
Farmers $1,121 $200,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026
Allstate $1,683 $200,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026
Nationwide $1,929 $200,000 dwelling ValuePenguin, Aug 2026

ValuePenguin notes the most expensive company in Idaho costs nearly three times as much as the cheapest for the same coverage. That gap is the whole argument for getting quotes from three or four carriers instead of renewing on autopilot. Mutual of Enumclaw is cheapest in about 57 percent of Idaho cities, State Farm in 36 percent, with Grange and Travelers cheapest in the rest. USAA posts low rates too, at $1,350 a year in the same table, but it only writes policies for military members, veterans, and their families.

How much is homeowners insurance in Idaho by city?

Boise has the cheapest home insurance in Idaho, at $1,608 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, according to ValuePenguin. State Farm is the cheapest carrier in Boise at $998 a year. Fenn, a small community near the Nez Perce Reservation, has the most expensive coverage in the state at $2,012 a year, which ValuePenguin links to fire risk and its rural location.

City Average per year Cheapest company Cheapest rate per year
Boise $1,608 State Farm $998
Caldwell $1,672 State Farm $966
Burley $1,677 State Farm $999
Coeur d’Alene $1,679 State Farm $922
Ammon $1,885 Mutual of Enumclaw $1,047
Fenn $2,012 Not published Not published

All city figures in that table are ValuePenguin, August 2026, for $350,000 of dwelling coverage. NerdWallet prices Boise differently: $2,170 a year at $400,000 of dwelling coverage, against a statewide $2,195 in the same study. Boise runs slightly below the state average in both studies, just at a different coverage level. The spread between Boise and Fenn is $404 a year, which is the price of location and fire risk in one state.

How much have Idaho home insurance rates risen?

Idaho home insurance rates went up by more than 50 percent in the past five years, a bit more than the national average, according to ValuePenguin. The increases were steep in 2023 and 2024, then slowed sharply in 2025. The pattern matters because a quote from two years ago tells you little about what the same house costs to insure now.

Year Rate increase
2021 2.19%
2022 4.66%
2023 17.20%
2024 15.33%
2025 3.46%

The rate change data comes from RateWatch by S and P Global, built on National Association of Insurance Commissioners filings. Not every carrier moved the same way. Farm Bureau did not raise rates at all over the five years. State Farm and Chubb raised theirs by less than 23 percent and 25 percent. Liberty Mutual raised rates by more than 88 percent, and Auto-Owners and Nationwide both raised theirs by more than 78 percent. A carrier that was cheap in 2021 may not be cheap now, which is another reason to re-shop at renewal.

What does homeowners insurance cover in Idaho, and what does it leave out?

A standard Idaho homeowners policy covers fire, including wildfire, and it covers water damage from a broken pipe or a leaking appliance. It does not cover flood damage, and it almost never covers earthquakes. Those two gaps matter in Idaho more than in most states, because the state has real wildfire, flood, and earthquake exposure in different regions.

Wildfire is the largest natural threat to Idaho homes. The state had 12 wildfires that each did at least $1 billion in damage between 2006 and 2024, according to NOAA data cited by ValuePenguin, and it averaged a billion dollar drought every 1.8 years over the same period. There were 440 wildfires in Idaho in 2024. One factor works in homeowners’ favor: less than 9 percent of buildings in the state sit in a high fire risk area, according to Verisk. If you live in a high risk area, some companies will not sell you fire coverage, and a separate wildfire policy may be the only option.

Water is the top cause of damage to Idaho homes by repair cost, according to ValuePenguin, mostly from mundane causes like leaking pipes and older roofs rather than weather. Flood is a smaller risk here: the National Flood Insurance Program paid only 35 claims in Idaho between 2020 and 2025. Earthquake coverage is a separate question. Parts of central and eastern Idaho are prone to earthquakes, including larger towns such as Rexburg and Idaho Falls, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. A standard policy does not cover earth movement, so a homeowner in those areas needs a separate earthquake endorsement or policy.

How does Idaho compare with its neighbors?

Idaho sits in the middle of its region on price. ValuePenguin puts Idaho at $1,759 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage. Rates in Nevada, Oregon, Utah, and Washington run lower. Rates in Wyoming and Montana run at least 19 percent higher. Our own state guides put Wyoming at $2,101 a year and Utah at $1,656 a year on the same $350,000 basis, so the regional spread is roughly $450 a year between Utah and Wyoming, with Idaho near the bottom of that range.

The reason is risk, not generosity. Idaho has fewer damaging floods than most states, most of its buildings sit outside high fire risk zones, and its population is spread out, which keeps rebuild costs and claim frequency down. The trade is that the state is not cheap everywhere: rural towns with fire exposure and long fire department response times pay more than Boise, sometimes by hundreds of dollars a year for the same house.

Worked example: what a Boise homeowner actually pays

Take a Boise homeowner with a house that would cost $350,000 to rebuild, a $1,000 deductible, good credit, and no recent claims. The Boise average is $1,608 a year, according to ValuePenguin. State Farm quotes $998 a year for that same profile in Boise. The gap between the city average and the cheapest quote is $610 a year, or about $51 a month, for identical coverage on the same house.

Now take the same house in Fenn, where the average is $2,012 a year. The location alone adds about $400 a year over Boise before any carrier difference. That is why a statewide average is only a starting point. Two Idaho homeowners with the same house can pay $1,000 a year apart once city, carrier, and coverage are all counted.

How to lower your Idaho homeowners insurance bill

Start with three quotes, and include at least one regional carrier. Mutual of Enumclaw and Grange beat the national brands in most Idaho cities, and State Farm leads in the rest. A quote from all three takes an afternoon and can save hundreds a year.

Raise the deductible if you can cover it. Moving from $1,000 to $2,500 usually cuts the premium by a visible amount, and it keeps small claims off your record. Bundle home and auto with the same carrier when the bundle discount beats the standalone prices, but check the math: a bundle is not always cheaper than two separate cheap policies.

Fix the roof before the insurer prices it. Our roof age guide explains how an older roof raises rates and can push a claim to actual cash value instead of full replacement cost. A new roof is expensive, but it is also one of the few home improvements that pays back in insurance savings. Ask about discounts for a monitored alarm, smoke detectors, and updated wiring and plumbing, and keep your credit score in good shape, since Idaho carriers use it in pricing.

Key takeaways

  • Idaho homeowners insurance averages $1,759 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, per ValuePenguin, or $2,195 a year for $400,000, per NerdWallet. The datasets disagree because they price different houses.
  • State Farm is cheapest for most Idaho homes at $1,054 a year. Mutual of Enumclaw is cheapest for homes under $350,000 to rebuild, at $736 a year for $200,000 of coverage.
  • Boise is the cheapest city at $1,608 a year. Fenn is the most expensive at $2,012 a year. The gap is fire risk and rural location.
  • Rates rose more than 50 percent in five years, with 17 percent in 2023 and 15 percent in 2024, then only 3.46 percent in 2025.
  • A standard policy covers wildfire and pipe leaks. It does not cover flood or earthquake damage, and central and eastern Idaho carry real earthquake risk.

Frequently asked questions

How much is homeowners insurance in Idaho in 2026?

Homeowners insurance in Idaho costs $1,759 a year on average for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, according to ValuePenguin, or $2,195 a year for $400,000 of coverage, according to NerdWallet. Insurify puts the average at $1,740 a year for $300,000 of coverage. The figures differ because each study prices a different sample home.

Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in Idaho?

State Farm has the cheapest home insurance in Idaho for most people, at $1,054 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, according to ValuePenguin. Mutual of Enumclaw is cheapest for homes that would cost less than $350,000 to rebuild, at $736 a year for $200,000 of coverage. Grange is also affordable at every dwelling level.

Does homeowners insurance in Idaho cover wildfire damage?

Yes, a standard home insurance policy covers fire damage, including damage caused by wildfires. Homeowners in high risk areas may find some companies will not sell them fire coverage, and a separate wildfire policy may be needed. Less than 9 percent of buildings in Idaho sit in a high fire risk area, according to Verisk.

Does homeowners insurance in Idaho cover flood damage?

No, a standard homeowners policy does not cover flood damage. Flood insurance is a separate policy, usually through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private carrier. Flood risk is relatively low in Idaho: the National Flood Insurance Program paid only 35 claims in the state between 2020 and 2025.

Does homeowners insurance in Idaho cover earthquakes?

No, a standard policy almost never covers earthquakes or other earth movement. Parts of central and eastern Idaho, including Rexburg and Idaho Falls, are prone to earthquakes, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. Homeowners in those areas need a separate earthquake endorsement or policy.

Why is homeowners insurance cheaper in Boise than in rural Idaho?

Boise averages $1,608 a year while Fenn averages $2,012, a gap of $404 a year. The difference comes down to fire risk, rural location, and fire department response times. Boise also has more carriers competing for the same homes, which keeps prices down.

ValuePenguin publishes its Idaho figures in its best and cheapest home insurance in Idaho guide, updated August 11, 2026, built from Quadrant Information Services rate data across every Idaho ZIP code. NerdWallet publishes its Idaho figures in its average homeowners insurance cost guide, updated March 17, 2026. Insurify publishes its Idaho figures in its Idaho home insurance study, updated August 10, 2026. For the neighboring states, see our Wyoming homeowners insurance guide and our Utah homeowners insurance guide. For Idaho auto coverage, see our Idaho car insurance guide.