Home Insurance

How Much Is Homeowners Insurance in Wyoming in 2026? Cheyenne, Casper, and the Real Average

Homeowners insurance in Wyoming costs $2,101 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, per ValuePenguin, or $1,805 for a $400,000 dwelling, per NerdWallet. State Farm is cheapest at $1,870 a year, Cheyenne runs $2,702 a year against $1,660 in Bedford, and wildfire risk around Cheyenne drives the southeast premium.

On this page

Homeowners insurance in Wyoming costs $2,101 a year on average in 2026 for a $350,000 dwelling policy, according to ValuePenguin, or about $175 a month. Other datasets put the same state average anywhere from $1,681 to $2,396 a year, because they price different houses with different methods. This post lays out what each dataset actually measures, what Wyoming homeowners pay by city and carrier, and what moves your own premium.

The spread between sources is worth understanding before you shop. NerdWallet prices a $400,000 dwelling for a 40 year old homeowner with good credit. ValuePenguin prices a $350,000 dwelling for a 45 year old married man with no claims. Insurify uses real quotes for a $300,000 dwelling. MoneyGeek prices a $250,000 dwelling for a homeowner aged 41 to 60. A bigger house costs more to insure, so the $400,000 figures run higher by design. None of these numbers is wrong. They answer slightly different questions, and the honest way to read them is side by side.

How much is homeowners insurance in Wyoming in 2026?

For a $350,000 dwelling with a $1,000 deductible, Wyoming homeowners pay about $2,101 a year, or $175 a month, according to ValuePenguin. That is about 12 percent below the national average of $2,395 a year for the same coverage in the same study. For a $400,000 dwelling, NerdWallet puts the Wyoming average at $1,805 a year, or $150 a month, against a national average of $2,490.

Source Dwelling coverage Average per year Average per month
ValuePenguin (Sept 2026) $350,000 $2,101 $175
NerdWallet (May 2026) $400,000 $1,805 $150
Insurify (Nov 2026) $300,000 $1,681 $140
Insurance.com (Oct 2026) $300,000 $2,075 $173
MoneyGeek (Aug 2026) $250,000 $1,893 $158
LendingTree (2026) Standard policy $2,396 $200
InsuranceQuotes (Sept 2026) $300,000 sample home $1,778 $148

One more figure puts the study averages in context. MonitorBankRates, analyzing U.S. Census Bureau cost data for Wyoming, reports that homeowners in the state pay a median of $1,642 a year. That figure counts every policy in force, including older homes with low dwelling limits and longtime customers with loyalty discounts. The study figures above price one sample home at current filed rates. Use the study figures to compare companies and the Census based median as a reminder that your own quote depends on your house.

ValuePenguin also publishes a national table that lists Wyoming at $1,208 a year, which conflicts with its own Wyoming page figure of $2,101. The two pages use different samples and update on different schedules. The state page figure is the one built from Wyoming ZIP codes, so this post uses $2,101 as the ValuePenguin number and notes the conflict rather than hiding it. The same kind of gap shows up across the datasets: Insurance.com averages $2,075 for a $300,000 dwelling while Insurify averages $1,681 for the same limit, a $394 spread that comes down to sample homes, quote dates, and which carriers each study includes.

Wyoming sits in the cheap half of the country for home insurance, but the states around it tell a different story. ValuePenguin prices the same $350,000 policy at $4,956 a year in Nebraska, the second highest rate in the nation, and $4,310 in Colorado. Idaho runs $1,759 and Utah $1,656, the only two border states cheaper than Wyoming. A Wyoming homeowner who moves south across the state line can see the premium more than double for the same house, which is why the state average on its own says little without the regional comparison.

Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in Wyoming?

State Farm has the cheapest home insurance in Wyoming for most people, at $1,870 a year for $350,000 in dwelling coverage, according to ValuePenguin. USAA posts lower rates, but only military members, veterans, and some family members can buy it. Allstate has the cheapest rate for new homes, at $770 a year, according to the same ValuePenguin study.

Company Average per year Source and coverage
State Farm $1,870 ValuePenguin, $350,000 dwelling
USAA, military only $1,320 Insurify, $110 a month, $300,000 dwelling
State Farm $1,572 Insurify, $131 a month, $300,000 dwelling
State Farm $1,555 MoneyGeek, $250,000 dwelling
USAA, military only $1,480 MoneyGeek, $250,000 dwelling
State Farm $1,724 Insurance.com, $300,000 dwelling
State Farm $1,750 LendingTree, $400,000 dwelling
USAA, military only $1,165 LendingTree, $400,000 dwelling
State Farm $1,649 InsuranceQuotes, $300,000 sample home
Allstate $1,884 Insurify, $157 a month, $300,000 dwelling

The cheapest carrier changes with the house. Allstate is the cheapest option for a newly built home, at $770 a year in ValuePenguin data, while State Farm wins for the typical 48 year old Wyoming home the study prices. Farmers averages $2,299 a year for a $300,000 dwelling in Insurance.com data, and Allstate averages $2,840 for the same coverage, so a carrier that is cheap for one house can be the expensive one for another. USAA also earns the fewest complaints relative to its size in NAIC data cited by ValuePenguin, while State Farm draws an average complaint level and Allstate a high one. Price and service point in different directions here: State Farm wins on price for most people, USAA wins on both price and complaints for those who can buy it.

MoneyGeek adds a useful local detail. USAA has the cheapest rates in Albin and Cheyenne, while State Farm has the cheapest rates in Laramie and Lyman, where it averages $943 and $919 a year respectively for the $250,000 dwelling profile. Where you live in Wyoming decides which carrier gives you the best deal, so a statewide cheapest list is a starting point and the ZIP code quote is the answer.

What Wyoming homeowners pay by city

Cheyenne, the capital and biggest city, costs $2,702 a year on average for a $350,000 dwelling, according to ValuePenguin, which is 29 percent above the state average. Casper runs $2,423. The cheapest town in the study is Bedford, a small town in western Wyoming near Bridger-Teton National Forest, at $1,660 a year. The most expensive is Carpenter, a small community southeast of Cheyenne, at $2,926 a year.

City Average per year Cheapest company Cheapest rate per year
Bedford $1,660 State Farm $1,183
Cody $1,779 State Farm $1,183
Casper $2,423 State Farm $2,400
Cheyenne $2,702 State Farm $2,727
Carpenter $2,926 Farmers $2,909

Insurance.com prices the same cities differently because it uses a different sample home, and the gap is a useful warning about taking any single city table as gospel. It puts Cheyenne at $1,883 a year and Casper at $1,687, with Evanston, Green River, and Rock Springs the cheapest cities at $1,173. InsuranceQuotes, pricing one sample home across 27 Wyoming ZIP codes, puts the lowest ZIP code in Cody at $1,433 a year and the highest in Cheyenne at $2,246. The three studies agree on the shape, Cheyenne and the southeast corner cost the most and the western towns cost the least, and disagree on the exact dollars. Insurify agrees on the shape too: Cheyenne homeowners pay the highest rates in the state, while Rock Springs homeowners pay the lowest.

The southeast corner costs more because of wildfire exposure. ValuePenguin notes that the area around Cheyenne carries the highest wildfire risk in the state, and that pushes premiums up even though the city sits on the plains rather than in the mountains. A homeowner in Cody pays roughly $900 a year less than a homeowner in Cheyenne for the same dwelling limit, and most of that gap is the fire and storm risk priced into the southeast.

One quirk in the ValuePenguin city table is worth flagging rather than smoothing over. Its Cheyenne row lists State Farm at $2,727 a year against a city average of $2,702, which puts the cheapest company above the average. That is the figure as published, and it shows why a single company row should be checked against a live quote instead of taken as exact. The Bedford row is clean by comparison: State Farm at $1,183 against a town average of $1,660.

What pushes Wyoming rates up: wildfire, wind, and hail

Wildfire is the risk that shapes Wyoming pricing most. More than 16,000 homes in Wyoming carry a moderate or high risk of wildfire damage, according to Cotality data cited by ValuePenguin, and rebuilding all of them would cost $5.7 billion. A standard home insurance policy covers fire damage, including damage from wildfires, but homeowners in high risk areas around Cheyenne may need a separate fire insurance policy if the standard market will not write the home. Wyoming has no state run FAIR plan, according to LendingTree, so a homeowner who cannot get a policy on the regular market should talk to an independent agent rather than waiting for a state program.

Wind and hail are the everyday claims. Windstorms caused $688,000 in damage in Wyoming in 2025, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and the state recorded 106 hailstorms in 2025 that caused about $1 million in damage, also per NOAA. Those numbers look small next to states with big cities, but Wyoming has the smallest population in the country, so the damage per household is high. Hail commonly damages roofs and siding, and wind can tear off shingles across a whole neighborhood in one storm.

The deductible is where wind and hail cost lands on the homeowner. Many Wyoming policies carry a separate wind and hail deductible, usually 1 to 5 percent of the dwelling limit, instead of the flat $1,000 deductible on the rest of the policy. On a $350,000 home, a 1 percent wind and hail deductible means $3,500 out of pocket before the insurer pays on a hail claim, and a 5 percent deductible means $17,500. Roof age matters too: if the roof and siding are not in good shape, the carrier may settle a claim at actual cash value, the depreciated value, instead of full replacement cost.

A worked example: the same house in Bedford and Cheyenne

Take a $350,000 dwelling with a $1,000 deductible. In Bedford, the town average is $1,660 a year and State Farm averages $1,183, which is $477 below the town average. In Cheyenne, the city average is $2,702 a year. The same house costs about $1,000 a year more to insure in the capital than in a small western town, and the gap is almost entirely the wildfire and storm risk priced into the southeast corner. A homeowner who takes the first renewal quote instead of comparing three carriers can easily pay $400 to $800 a year more for the same coverage on the same house. The gap is the whole story in Wyoming: the state average is low, but the spread between towns and carriers is wide.

How to pay less for homeowners insurance in Wyoming

Start by deciding how much coverage you actually need. Most basic policies cover the structure, your belongings, liability, and extra living costs, but the dwelling limit should match rebuild cost, not market value. A home that would cost $300,000 to rebuild does not need $400,000 of dwelling coverage, and the extra limit adds premium for nothing. ValuePenguin prices the jump from a $350,000 dwelling to a $500,000 dwelling at about $900 a year, so overshooting the limit is an expensive mistake.

Get quotes from at least three companies, and include State Farm and one regional carrier. USAA is worth a quote if anyone in the household is eligible, since it posts the lowest rates in the state and the fewest complaints. Ask each carrier about the same discounts: bundling home and auto, a new roof, a monitored alarm, and a higher deductible. Raising the deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 cuts the premium, but only take the higher deductible if you can pay it after a storm without borrowing.

Your credit score shapes the price more than most homeowners expect. Our guide to how a credit score affects homeowners insurance premiums explains which states limit the practice and how much a lower score can add. Roof age matters too: our guide to how roof age affects homeowners insurance rates covers when a carrier switches a roof to actual cash value settlement. Bundling helps in Wyoming as well, and our Wyoming car insurance guide shows what the auto side of a bundle costs. For comparison with the states around Wyoming, see our Colorado homeowners insurance guide, our Nebraska homeowners insurance guide, and our Montana homeowners insurance guide.

What to remember about Wyoming homeowners insurance

Wyoming homeowners pay $2,101 a year on average for a $350,000 dwelling, or $1,805 for a $400,000 dwelling, depending on which house the dataset prices. State Farm is cheapest for most people at $1,870 a year, USAA is cheaper still for military households, and the city you live in moves the price by more than $1,200 a year. Wildfire risk around Cheyenne is the main reason the southeast costs more, and wind and hail deductibles are the detail to check before a storm rather than after one.

Frequently asked questions

How much is homeowners insurance in Wyoming?

Homeowners insurance in Wyoming costs $2,101 a year on average for a $350,000 dwelling, according to ValuePenguin, or $1,805 a year for a $400,000 dwelling, according to NerdWallet. The two figures price different houses, so the gap is a method difference rather than a disagreement about the market.

How much is home insurance in Cheyenne, WY?

Home insurance in Cheyenne costs an average of $2,702 a year for a $350,000 dwelling, according to ValuePenguin, which is 29 percent above the state average. Insurance.com prices the same city lower, at $1,883 a year for a different sample home, so the exact figure depends on the house being priced.

Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in Wyoming?

State Farm has the cheapest home insurance in Wyoming for most people, with an average rate of $1,870 a year for $350,000 in dwelling coverage, according to ValuePenguin. USAA has lower rates but is only available to military members, veterans, and some family members.

Does homeowners insurance in Wyoming cover wildfire damage?

Yes, a standard home insurance policy covers fire damage, including damage caused by wildfires. Homeowners in high risk areas around Cheyenne may need a separate fire insurance policy if the standard market will not write the home, and Wyoming has no state run FAIR plan as a fallback.

Does homeowners insurance in Wyoming cover hail damage?

Yes, a standard policy covers hail damage to the roof and siding. Many Wyoming policies carry a separate wind and hail deductible, usually 1 to 5 percent of the dwelling limit, which is higher than the regular $1,000 deductible. An older roof may also be settled at actual cash value rather than full replacement cost.

Is homeowners insurance required in Wyoming?

No, Wyoming does not require homeowners to carry home insurance. A mortgage lender will almost always require it, and a homeowner with no mortgage can technically skip coverage, but then repair and rebuild costs fall entirely on the homeowner after a loss.

NerdWallet publishes its Wyoming figures in its average homeowners insurance cost guide, updated May 6, 2026. ValuePenguin publishes its Wyoming figures in its best cheap home insurance in Wyoming guide, updated September 25, 2026, built from Quadrant Information Services rate data across 182 Wyoming ZIP codes. Storm and hail counts come from the NOAA National Weather Service Storm Prediction Center as reported by ValuePenguin. For a wildfire heavy comparison, see our Colorado homeowners insurance guide.