On this page
Homeowners insurance in Utah costs $1,656 a year on average in 2026 for a $350,000 dwelling policy, according to ValuePenguin, or about $138 a month. That is 31 percent below the national average of $2,395 a year for the same coverage. Utah is one of the cheapest states in the country to insure a home, but the average hides a sharp rise: Utah rates climbed 72 percent in five years, and the cheapest carrier in the state nearly doubled its prices over the same period. This post lays out the current averages, the cheapest carriers, city rates, and the earthquake gap most Utah homeowners miss.
The datasets disagree by a few hundred dollars, and the reason is the house each one prices. NerdWallet prices a $400,000 dwelling for a 40 year old homeowner with good credit. ValuePenguin prices a $350,000 dwelling for a 45 year old married man with no claims. Insurify uses real quotes for a $300,000 dwelling. MoneyGeek prices a $250,000 dwelling for a homeowner aged 41 to 60. A bigger house costs more to insure, so the $400,000 figures run higher by design. Read the tables with the dwelling limit in mind and the disagreement mostly disappears.
How much is homeowners insurance in Utah in 2026?
For a $350,000 dwelling with a $1,000 deductible, Utah homeowners pay about $1,656 a year, or $138 a month, according to ValuePenguin. For a $400,000 dwelling, NerdWallet puts the Utah average at $1,810 a year, or $151 a month, against a national average of $2,490. For a $300,000 dwelling, Insurify averages $1,524 a year.
| Source | Dwelling coverage | Average per year | Average per month |
|---|---|---|---|
| ValuePenguin (Sept 2026) | $350,000 | $1,656 | $138 |
| NerdWallet (May 2026) | $400,000 | $1,810 | $151 |
| Insurify (Nov 2026) | $300,000 | $1,524 | $127 |
| MoneyGeek (Nov 2026) | $250,000 | $1,454 | $121 |
| InsuranceQuotes (Sept 2026) | Sample home | $2,108 | $176 |
InsuranceQuotes runs higher than the rest because it prices one specific sample home across all 106 Utah ZIP codes and compares only five insurers, including Liberty Mutual at $249 a month, which pulls its average up. Its value is the carrier spread it shows, not the headline average: Farmers prices the same house at $85 a month while Liberty Mutual prices it at $249, a $204 a month gap for identical coverage.
ValuePenguin also publishes a national table that lists Utah at $1,137 a year, which conflicts with its own Utah page figure of $1,656. The two pages use different samples and update on different schedules. The state page figure is the one built from Utah ZIP codes, so this post uses $1,656 as the ValuePenguin number and notes the conflict rather than hiding it. The same pattern showed up in the Wyoming data, where the national table and the state page also disagree by a wide margin.
Utah’s price depends heavily on how much house you insure. ValuePenguin prices a $200,000 dwelling at $1,063 a year, a $350,000 dwelling at $1,656, a $500,000 dwelling at $2,210, and a $1 million dwelling at $3,947. The step from $350,000 to $500,000 of dwelling coverage adds about $550 a year, so a dwelling limit set above rebuild cost is money spent for nothing.
Utah home insurance rates rose 72 percent in five years
Home insurance prices in Utah rose 72 percent between 2021 and 2025, according to ValuePenguin and S and P Global RateWatch data drawn from National Association of Insurance Commissioners filings. The increases came in two big jumps, about 21 percent in 2023 and about 21 percent again in 2024, then slowed to 3.24 percent in 2025. Utah homeowners who bought in 2021 and never shopped again are paying for a market that no longer exists.
The increases did not hit every carrier the same way. Farmers, the cheapest carrier in the state, had the third highest price increase in Utah between 2021 and 2025, at 95 percent. A carrier can nearly double its rates over five years and still be the cheapest option today if it started low enough, which is exactly what happened with Farmers. The trend matters less than the current quote for your house, and a carrier that held its rates down for five years can still be the expensive one today if it started high.
The 2025 slowdown is the most useful number in the trend table. A 3 percent rise after two years of 21 percent rises suggests the market is cooling, but it does not mean rates will fall. Rebuild costs, wildfire exposure, and earthquake risk along the Wasatch Front keep upward pressure on Utah premiums, and the cheapest way to respond is still a fresh set of quotes rather than waiting for the market to turn.
Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in Utah?
Farmers has the cheapest home insurance in Utah for most people, according to ValuePenguin, and MoneyGeek puts its average at $826 a year for a $250,000 dwelling. State Farm has the most affordable rates for high value homes, according to ValuePenguin, and averages $1,123 a year in MoneyGeek data for the same $250,000 profile. Foremost is the cheapest carrier in Insurify data, at $786 a year for a $300,000 dwelling, with Farmers next at $884.
| Company | Average per year | Source and coverage |
|---|---|---|
| Farmers | $826 | MoneyGeek, $250,000 dwelling |
| Foremost | $786 | Insurify, $300,000 dwelling |
| Farmers | $884 | Insurify, $300,000 dwelling |
| State Farm | $1,123 | MoneyGeek, $250,000 dwelling |
| American Family | $1,243 | MoneyGeek, $250,000 dwelling |
| Farmers | $1,015 | InsuranceQuotes, sample home |
| State Farm | $1,625 | InsuranceQuotes, sample home |
| USAA, military only | $1,452 | InsuranceQuotes, $121 a month, sample home |
Farmers is the cheapest carrier in about half of Utah cities and towns, including Salt Lake City, according to ValuePenguin. Nationwide has the most affordable rates in 23 percent of the remaining towns, while State Farm is cheapest in 16 percent and Allstate in 11 percent. Mutual of Enumclaw and Nationwide earn the best ratings in the state in ValuePenguin’s review, so a homeowner who wants the cheapest price and a homeowner who wants the best rated carrier may end up with different companies. American Family earns the top overall score in MoneyGeek’s Utah review at 4.5 out of 5, with the lowest premiums among its top rated group, and it is the cheapest carrier in Bountiful, Mexican Hat, Veyo, and West Jordan in that data.
What Utah homeowners pay by city
Utah city rates sit in a narrow band, which is unusual for a state with this much terrain. Insurify prices a $300,000 dwelling at $1,560 a year in Ogden, $1,560 in Provo, and $1,584 in Salt Lake City, a spread of just $24 across the three biggest cities on the Wasatch Front. The cheapest town in ValuePenguin data is Kingston, a small rural town in south central Utah, at around $1,428 a year.
| City | Average per year | Cheapest company | Cheapest rate per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kingston | $1,428 | Not published | Not published |
| Cannonville | $1,515 | Nationwide | $734 |
| Cedar City | $1,563 | Nationwide | $793 |
| Alpine | $1,704 | Farmers | $914 |
| Brigham City | $1,931 | State Farm | $989 |
| Collinston | $2,015 | Farmers | $845 |
InsuranceQuotes prices the same cities higher because it uses a different sample home, and the gap is a useful warning about taking any single city table as gospel. It puts Salt Lake City at $2,088 a year, Provo at $2,105, and Ogden at $2,136, with the lowest ZIP code in Richfield at $1,991 a year and the highest in Midway at $2,274. MoneyGeek’s city data, built on the $250,000 dwelling profile, puts Farmers at $893 a year in Salt Lake City, $812 in Provo, $826 in West Jordan, $779 in West Valley City, and $818 in Bountiful. The three studies agree on the shape: the Wasatch Front cities cost roughly the same, small rural towns cost less, and the cheapest carrier in a given town beats the town average by a wide margin.
The earthquake gap: what a Utah policy does not cover
A standard homeowners insurance policy does not cover earthquake damage. That matters more in Utah than in most states, because the Wasatch Fault runs along the Wasatch Front through Salt Lake City, Provo, and Ogden, the same corridor where most Utah homeowners live. Earthquake coverage takes a separate endorsement or a separate policy, and it usually carries its own deductible as a percentage of the dwelling limit rather than a flat dollar amount.
Wildfire is the other Utah risk that catches homeowners by surprise. Homes near the foothills and in southern Utah canyon country face higher wildfire exposure, and carriers price that into the premium by ZIP code. A standard policy covers fire damage, including wildfire, but homes in the highest risk pockets can face higher deductibles or tighter eligibility. Flood is the third gap: home insurance almost never covers flood damage, and a separate flood policy from the National Flood Insurance Program or a private carrier is the only way to cover it.
The practical point is that the cheapest premium in Utah can be the wrong policy if it leaves the earthquake exposure uncovered. A homeowner in Salt Lake City should price an earthquake endorsement alongside the base policy and compare the combined cost, not the base premium alone. The endorsement adds cost, but the Wasatch Fault is the reason Utah rates carry the risk load they do, and skipping the coverage does not remove the risk.
A worked example: the same house in Salt Lake City
Take a $250,000 dwelling in Salt Lake City with a $1,000 deductible. The statewide average in MoneyGeek data is $1,454 a year, and Farmers averages $893 a year in the city, which is $561 below the state average. State Farm averages $1,127 a year in Salt Lake City in the same data. A homeowner who takes the first renewal quote instead of comparing three carriers can easily pay $500 a year more for the same coverage on the same house. The gap is the whole story in Utah: the state average is low, the cheapest carrier prices far below it, and the difference between carriers is bigger than the difference between cities.
How to pay less for homeowners insurance in Utah
Start by deciding how much coverage you actually need. Most basic policies cover the structure, your belongings, liability, and extra living costs, but the dwelling limit should match rebuild cost, not market value. A home that would cost $300,000 to rebuild does not need $400,000 of dwelling coverage, and the extra limit adds premium for nothing. ValuePenguin prices the jump from a $350,000 dwelling to a $500,000 dwelling at about $550 a year in Utah.
Get quotes from at least three companies, and include Farmers and State Farm, since one of the two is cheapest in most Utah towns. USAA is worth a quote if anyone in the household is eligible. Ask each carrier about the same discounts: bundling home and auto, a new roof, a monitored alarm, and a higher deductible. Raising the deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 cuts the premium, but only take the higher deductible if you can pay it after a loss without borrowing.
Your credit score shapes the price more than most homeowners expect. Our guide to how a credit score affects homeowners insurance premiums explains which states limit the practice and how much a lower score can add. Roof age matters too: our guide to how roof age affects homeowners insurance rates covers when a carrier switches a roof to actual cash value settlement. Bundling helps in Utah as well, and our Wyoming car insurance guide shows how the auto side of a bundle is priced in a neighboring state. For comparison with the states around Utah, see our Colorado homeowners insurance guide, our Montana homeowners insurance guide, and our South Dakota homeowners insurance guide.
What to remember about Utah homeowners insurance
Utah homeowners pay $1,656 a year on average for a $350,000 dwelling, or $1,810 for a $400,000 dwelling, depending on which house the dataset prices. Rates rose 72 percent in five years, but the 2025 increase slowed to about 3 percent. Farmers is cheapest for most people at $826 a year for a $250,000 dwelling, State Farm is cheapest for high value homes, and the city you live in moves the price far less than the carrier you pick. Check whether your policy covers earthquake damage, because a standard policy does not.
Frequently asked questions
How much is homeowners insurance in Utah?
Homeowners insurance in Utah costs $1,656 a year on average for a $350,000 dwelling, according to ValuePenguin, or $1,810 a year for a $400,000 dwelling, according to NerdWallet. The two figures price different houses, so the gap is a method difference rather than a disagreement about the market.
How much is home insurance in Salt Lake City, UT?
Home insurance in Salt Lake City costs an average of $1,584 a year for a $300,000 dwelling, according to Insurify. Farmers is the cheapest carrier in the city, at $893 a year for a $250,000 dwelling in MoneyGeek data.
Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in Utah?
Farmers has the cheapest home insurance in Utah for most people, with an average rate of $826 a year for a $250,000 dwelling, according to MoneyGeek. State Farm has the most affordable rates for high value homes, according to ValuePenguin, and Foremost is cheapest in Insurify data at $786 a year for a $300,000 dwelling.
Does homeowners insurance in Utah cover earthquakes?
No, a standard homeowners insurance policy does not cover earthquake damage. Utah homeowners along the Wasatch Front, including Salt Lake City, Provo, and Ogden, need a separate earthquake endorsement or policy, which usually carries its own deductible as a percentage of the dwelling limit.
Why did Utah home insurance rates rise 72 percent in five years?
Utah rates rose about 21 percent in 2023 and about 21 percent again in 2024, according to ValuePenguin and S and P Global RateWatch data, before slowing to about 3 percent in 2025. Rebuild costs, wildfire exposure, and earthquake risk along the Wasatch Front kept upward pressure on premiums through the period.
Is homeowners insurance required in Utah?
No, Utah does not require homeowners to carry home insurance. A mortgage lender will almost always require it, and a homeowner with no mortgage can technically skip coverage, but then repair and rebuild costs fall entirely on the homeowner after a loss.
NerdWallet publishes its Utah figures in its average homeowners insurance cost guide, updated May 6, 2026. ValuePenguin publishes its Utah figures in its best cheap home insurance in Utah guide, updated September 25, 2026, built from Quadrant Information Services rate data across all Utah residential ZIP codes. For a comparison with the state next door, see our Wyoming homeowners insurance guide.
