On this page
CURE Auto Insurance is worth a quote if you are a safe driver in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, or Michigan with a clean record and a credit score that other insurers punish you for. CURE prices policies mainly on your driving history and does not use credit score, education, or occupation to set rates, which is rare in auto insurance. The tradeoff is real: ValuePenguin’s September 2026 rate comparison found CURE more expensive than GEICO for most sample drivers, and customer reviews split between praise for low minimum-coverage prices and complaints about claims service. This review covers what CURE costs, what it covers, where it falls short, and who should get a quote.
What is CURE Auto Insurance?
CURE stands for Citizens United Reciprocal Exchange. It is a not-for-profit reciprocal insurer founded in New Jersey in the 1980s, during the state’s car insurance crisis, and it still operates from Princeton, New Jersey. Its NAIC company code is 37028. CURE sells auto insurance in exactly three states: New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Michigan. It entered Michigan in July 2021 and had insured about 75,000 Michigan drivers by August 2023, according to Grandfolk’s review.
CURE’s pitch is simple and it repeats it everywhere: your premium should reflect how you drive, not how much money you make or how far you went in school. Most insurers weigh credit score, education, and occupation heavily when they price a policy. CURE says it has never used those factors. That makes it a genuine alternative for drivers whose record is clean but whose credit or job history works against them at national carriers. It also means CURE is a poor fit for drivers whose record is the problem, since driving history is almost all CURE looks at.
Being a reciprocal exchange also shapes the company. Policyholders are members rather than customers of a shareholder-owned insurer, and the company describes itself as not-for-profit. That does not make it cheap for everyone, and it does not mean it carries the financial strength ratings of a national carrier. CURE is not rated by A.M. Best, which matters if you care about an independent read on an insurer’s ability to pay claims.
How much does CURE Auto Insurance cost?
CURE’s prices depend heavily on who you are, which is the honest answer for any insurer but especially true here. Clearsurance reports minimum coverage starting at about $25 a month and full coverage around $119 a month. ValuePenguin’s September 2026 comparison, based on quoted rates for New Jersey drivers, tells a more mixed story: CURE came out more expensive than GEICO for most of its sample drivers, but cheaper than Progressive for a single 30-year-old man.
| Sample driver, New Jersey | CURE, per year | GEICO, per year | Progressive, per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single man, age 30 | $1,026 | $716 | $1,076 |
| Married couple, age 35 | $1,252 | $507 | $887 |
| Married couple, age 65 | $1,171 | $489 | $884 |
The married-couple rows are the ones to study. CURE was more than twice GEICO’s price for a married 35-year-old couple, and more than twice Progressive’s discount is not the issue. CURE’s rating model leans on the primary driver’s record, and married couples with two drivers and two cars do not get the multi-driver pricing breaks that national carriers build in. Single drivers with clean records are where CURE competes. A single 30-year-old man paid less at CURE than at Progressive in ValuePenguin’s sample, though GEICO still beat both.
Grandfolk’s review puts CURE’s average full coverage at $1,968 a year, which is higher than ValuePenguin’s figures, and that gap shows how much the sample profile matters. Different driver profiles, different states, different coverage limits. Treat any single average as a starting point, not a quote. The only number that matters is the one CURE quotes you, next to the quotes you get from two or three other carriers for the same coverage.
What does CURE cover, and what discounts exist?
CURE sells the standard auto coverages: liability, collision, comprehensive, medical payments, personal injury protection where the state requires it, and uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. In New Jersey it offers both a basic policy and a standard policy. The basic policy meets the state’s minimum requirements at a lower price. The standard policy carries higher liability limits and more protection. If you are choosing between them, read the limits carefully. A basic policy that satisfies the state minimum can still leave you paying out of pocket after a serious crash.
CURE’s discount list is short, and the one that matters most rewards staying claim-free. The loss-free discount grows the longer you go without a claim on your CURE policy: 5 percent after two claim-free years, 10 percent after three years, and 20 percent after five or more years, according to ValuePenguin. That is a meaningful discount for a driver who stays put, and it is one reason CURE works best as a long-term choice rather than a one-year stopgap. Our guide to claim-free discounts on car insurance explains how other carriers reward clean records and how those discounts compare.
What CURE does not offer is the long menu of add-ons national carriers sell. There is no usage-based telematics program, no accident forgiveness product to buy, and fewer bundling options, since CURE sells auto insurance only. If you want one company for your car, your home, and your renters policy, CURE cannot do that. If you want a simple auto policy priced on your record, the short menu is a feature rather than a gap.
What do customers say about CURE?
Customer reviews of CURE split in a pattern that tells you a lot about the company. On price and on service before a claim, reviewers are often happy. Clearsurance notes Reddit users with clean records in New Jersey and Michigan reporting friendly service and prompt responses by phone and online. Grandfolk gives CURE 3.8 stars out of 5 and reports praise for affordable rates and a smooth claims process from some customers. InsuranceOnCheap aggregates a 3.4-star rating across 3,836 reviews.
The other side of the split is claims. The same sources report drivers who filed claims finding it hard to reach an agent, and complaints about delays and low settlements. InsurancePanda rates CURE 1.9 out of 5 and reports that CURE draws far more complaints than expected for its size, based on NAIC private passenger auto complaint data from 2023 to 2025. It also notes that CURE has no 2026 J.D. Power rating it could confirm, which means there is no independent satisfaction benchmark to check the review sites against.
Put together, the picture is a small regional carrier that treats good drivers well and struggles when claims get complicated. That is not unusual for a company of CURE’s size, but it is a real risk to weigh. A cheap premium is worth less if the claims process is slow when you need it. Before you switch, read the Better Business Bureau complaints for CURE, which InsurancePanda recommends as a pre-switch check, and pay attention to whether the complaints describe problems you could live with.
Is CURE cheaper than GEICO and Progressive?
For most drivers, no. ValuePenguin’s September 2026 comparison shows GEICO beating CURE on every sample profile it tested, sometimes by a wide margin. A married couple aged 35 paid $507 a year at GEICO against $1,252 at CURE. Progressive beat CURE for married couples too, though CURE edged Progressive for the single 30-year-old man. The drivers who save at CURE are the ones national carriers overcharge: safe drivers with poor credit, drivers without a college degree, and drivers whose occupation pushes their rate up elsewhere. CURE ignores those factors, so the comparison flips for them.
State matters as well. New Jersey has some of the highest auto insurance rates in the country, and CURE was built for that market. Michigan is a no-fault state with its own pricing quirks, and our guide to car insurance costs in Michigan explains how no-fault and PIP shape quotes there. Pennsylvania drivers sit in between. Get quotes in your own state and your own profile, because a national average will not tell you what CURE charges you.
For a broader sense of the market, our GEICO monthly cost guide and our Erie Insurance review cover two carriers that compete for the same safe-driver dollar in the same states, and our cheap car insurance guide lists where else to look if CURE’s quote comes back high.
Who should get a CURE quote?
Get a CURE quote if you live in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, or Michigan, you have a clean driving record, and your credit score, education, or occupation has pushed your rates up at national carriers. Get one too if you are a single driver rather than a married couple, since that is where CURE’s pricing is most competitive. And get one if you plan to stay with the same carrier for years, since the loss-free discount reaches 20 percent after five claim-free years.
Skip CURE if you live outside its three states, since you cannot buy it at all. Skip it if you want home and auto bundled with one carrier, if you want telematics or accident forgiveness, or if claims service is your top priority and the complaint data worries you. Married couples should compare carefully, because ValuePenguin’s numbers show CURE well behind GEICO and Progressive for two-driver households.
When you quote, do it properly. Use the same liability limits, the same deductibles, and the same drivers at every carrier, and ask CURE whether the quote is for its basic or standard policy in New Jersey. A cheap quote on a basic policy is not the same as a cheap quote on a standard one. Compare the loss-free discount too, since a policy that gets 20 percent cheaper after five clean years is worth more than a policy that starts cheap and stays flat.
Frequently asked questions
Is CURE Auto Insurance a good company?
CURE is a good fit for safe drivers in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Michigan whose credit or education history raises their rates elsewhere. It is not rated by A.M. Best, and its complaint ratio runs high for its size, so claims service is the main risk to weigh.
How much does CURE Auto Insurance cost?
Minimum coverage starts at about $25 a month, according to Clearsurance. ValuePenguin’s September 2026 New Jersey sample put CURE at $1,026 a year for a single 30-year-old man and $1,252 a year for a married couple aged 35. Your own quote depends on your record, state, and coverage.
What states does CURE cover?
New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Michigan only. CURE does not sell auto insurance anywhere else, so drivers outside those three states cannot buy a policy.
Does CURE use credit scores to set rates?
No. CURE prices policies mainly on driving history and says it has never used credit checks, education, or occupation to determine rates. That is the main reason drivers with poor credit but clean records save there.
What discounts does CURE offer?
The main discount is loss-free: 5 percent after two claim-free years, 10 percent after three years, and 20 percent after five or more years with CURE. The discount list beyond that is short compared with national carriers.
Is CURE cheaper than GEICO?
Usually not. ValuePenguin’s September 2026 comparison found GEICO cheaper than CURE for every sample driver it tested, including a married couple aged 35 at $507 a year against CURE’s $1,252. CURE competes best for single drivers with clean records and poor credit.
Sources: ValuePenguin CURE Auto Insurance Review (updated September 30, 2026; rate comparison and loss-free discount), Clearsurance CURE customer ratings (minimum coverage from $25 a month, three-state availability), Grandfolk CURE review (3.8 stars, Michigan entry 2021, 75,000 Michigan drivers), InsurancePanda CURE review (1.9 out of 5, NAIC complaint data 2023 to 2025, NAIC code 37028).
