On this page
The cheapest car insurance in Rhode Island is USAA, at $80 a month for liability only and $123 a month for full coverage, according to Insurify data updated November 18, 2026. USAA is open only to military members and their families. Among carriers open to everyone, the answer depends on which dataset you read: MoneyGeek names Quincy Insurance cheapest at $85 a month for full coverage, Insurify names State Farm at $159, and ValuePenguin names Travelers at $196.
Rhode Island is the second most expensive state for car insurance, with a full coverage average of $295 a month per Insurify, so the carrier choice matters more here than in most states. The cheapest quote and the most expensive quote for the same driver can sit $200 a month apart. This post compares every dataset, breaks the cheapest rate down by driver type and city, and explains why a small regional carrier beats the national names in one study and barely appears in the others.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Rhode Island?
USAA has the cheapest car insurance in Rhode Island for drivers who can buy it, at $80 a month for liability only and $123 a month for full coverage in Insurify data. ValuePenguin puts USAA even lower, at $50 a month for liability only and $124 a month for full coverage. Military members, veterans, and their families should quote USAA first, because it wins by a wide margin in both datasets.
For everyone else, MoneyGeek names Quincy Insurance cheapest at $85 a month for full coverage and $63 a month for minimum coverage, which is 37 percent below the state average of $134 a month. State Farm is second in MoneyGeek at $89 a month for full coverage and $66 for minimum, Travelers third at $99 and $84, Amica fourth at $102 and $93, and Progressive fifth at $151 and $120. Quincy is a regional carrier focused on New England, and it is the cheapest company in Rhode Island while barely appearing in the national datasets.
Insurify and ValuePenguin tell a different story. Insurify names State Farm cheapest among open-market carriers at $103 a month for liability only and $159 for full coverage, with Safeco at $119 and $231, Direct Auto at $159 and $298, and Allstate at $168 and $288. ValuePenguin names Travelers cheapest at $63 a month for liability only and $196 for full coverage, with Progressive second at $77 and $212. The three datasets price different drivers, and the winner changes with the profile.
Cheapest full coverage in Rhode Island, by dataset
| Company | Insurify | ValuePenguin | MoneyGeek | Quadrant |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| USAA | $123/month | $124/month | Not listed | $151/month |
| Quincy | Not listed | Not listed | $85/month | Not listed |
| State Farm | $159/month | Not listed | $89/month | Not listed |
| Travelers | $297/month | $196/month | $99/month | $186/month |
| Amica | Not listed | $306/month | $102/month | $254/month |
| Progressive | Not listed | $212/month | $151/month | $216/month |
| GEICO | $286/month | $276/month | Not listed | $300/month |
| Allstate | $288/month | $264/month | Not listed | $285/month |
Travelers shows the widest spread of any carrier: $99 a month in MoneyGeek data, $186 in Quadrant data, $196 in ValuePenguin data, and $297 in Insurify data. A driver who reads only the Insurify table would dismiss Travelers as one of the most expensive carriers in the state. A driver who reads only MoneyGeek would call it the third cheapest. Both readings are supported by real data, and the difference comes from the driver profile each dataset prices.
Amica shows the same pattern in reverse. MoneyGeek prices Amica at $102 a month for full coverage and ranks it first overall in Rhode Island with a 4.79 out of 5 score, driven by a perfect 5 out of 5 customer experience rating and a J.D. Power score of 735, which is 110 points above the regional average of 625. ValuePenguin prices the same company at $306 a month for full coverage and calls it the best for customer service but far from the cheapest. Amica is headquartered in Lincoln, Rhode Island, and its home-state advantage shows up in service scores more reliably than in price.
Cheapest minimum coverage in Rhode Island
Minimum coverage is where the smallest carriers win. MoneyGeek names Quincy cheapest at $63 a month, with State Farm at $66 and Travelers at $84. ValuePenguin names Travelers cheapest at $63 a month, with USAA at $50 for military drivers, Progressive at $77, GEICO at $103, and Amica at $104. Quadrant data analyzed by CheapCarInsurance.net names Amica cheapest for liability only at $62 a month, with Progressive at $67 and Travelers at $81.
| Company | Insurify | ValuePenguin | MoneyGeek | Quadrant |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| USAA | $80/month | $50/month | Not listed | $52/month |
| Quincy | Not listed | Not listed | $63/month | Not listed |
| Travelers | $193/month | $63/month | $84/month | $81/month |
| Amica | Not listed | $104/month | $93/month | $62/month |
| State Farm | $103/month | Not listed | $66/month | Not listed |
| Progressive | Not listed | $77/month | $120/month | $67/month |
Rhode Island requires 25/50/25 liability coverage: $25,000 bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident, and $25,000 property damage. A combined single limit of $75,000 is an accepted alternative. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage must be included unless the driver rejects it in writing, and about 9.9 percent of Rhode Island drivers are uninsured, so the coverage has real value here.
The step from minimum to full coverage is small at the cheapest carriers and large at the expensive ones. At Quincy, full coverage is $85 a month against $63 for minimum, a $22 step. At State Farm in Insurify data, full coverage is $159 against $103, a $56 step. At Travelers in ValuePenguin data, the step is $133 a month, from $63 to $196. A driver comparing minimum quotes should also compare the full coverage step, because the carrier that is cheapest for minimum is not always cheapest for full.
Cheapest car insurance in Rhode Island by driver type
Travelers is cheapest for full coverage for most driver types in the ValuePenguin analysis, and Progressive is cheapest after a speeding ticket at $297 a month, with Amica close behind at $306. MoneyGeek finds Travelers cheapest for drivers with a DUI at $89 a month for full coverage, the lowest of any top-five carrier for that record. The cheapest carrier for a clean-record driver is rarely the cheapest carrier for a driver with a violation, and the ranking reshuffles completely after a ticket or an accident.
| Driver type | Cheapest company | Monthly rate | Dataset |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clean record, full coverage | Quincy | $85 | MoneyGeek |
| Clean record, full coverage | Travelers | $196 | ValuePenguin |
| After a speeding ticket | Progressive | $297 | ValuePenguin |
| After a speeding ticket | Amica | $306 | ValuePenguin |
| After a DUI | Travelers | $89 | MoneyGeek |
| Military, full coverage | USAA | $123 | Insurify |
| Best customer service | Amica | $102 | MoneyGeek |
Teen drivers face the steepest prices in the state. Insurify puts the overall monthly average at $457 for teen drivers, against $250 for drivers in their 40s and $200 for seniors. Adding a teen to a family policy is usually cheaper than a standalone policy, and a good student discount plus a defensive driving course can bring the number down. A parent should re-quote when the teen turns 19 and again at 25, when the age band changes and the ranking shifts.
Allstate raised rates 4.1 percent in Rhode Island in 2026, and Mapfre raised rates 4.0 percent, according to ValuePenguin’s rate change table, with five-year increases of 16.3 percent and over 50 percent respectively. A driver with either carrier who has not re-shopped in the last year is likely paying more than the current cheapest quote, and the increase compounds: a 4 percent rise on an already expensive policy is a larger dollar amount than the same percentage on a cheap one.
Cheapest car insurance by Rhode Island city and ZIP code
Travelers has the cheapest full coverage insurance in 84 percent of Rhode Island cities and towns, including Providence and Warwick, according to ValuePenguin, with Progressive cheapest in the remaining 16 percent, including Newport. Quadrant data agrees on the company but disagrees on the margin: Travelers is lowest for full coverage in 52 of 53 ZIP codes, while Amica is lowest for liability only in 45 of 53 ZIP codes.
The ZIP code spread is wide for a state this small. Quadrant data shows that in 15 of the 53 Rhode Island ZIP codes, even the cheapest company charges $200 a month or more for full coverage. The five-company average for full coverage is $248 a month, or $2,977 a year, with Travelers at $186 and GEICO at $300. A driver in a high-priced ZIP code who buys from the cheapest carrier there still pays more than a driver in a low-priced ZIP code who buys from an average carrier.
Newport is the exception that proves the pattern. Progressive, not Travelers, is cheapest for full coverage in Newport in ValuePenguin data, and the coastal ZIP codes around Newport run higher than the inland ones. A driver who moves from Providence to Newport should re-quote rather than assume the same carrier is still cheapest, because the ranking changes with the ZIP code.
How to get the cheapest rate in Rhode Island
Quote USAA first if anyone in the household qualifies through military service. Then quote Quincy, State Farm, Travelers, and Amica, because those four cover the winner in every dataset. A driver who only checks the national names will miss Quincy, which is cheapest in MoneyGeek’s analysis and does not appear in the Insurify or ValuePenguin cheapest tables at all.
Compare the same coverage at every carrier, and compare both minimum and full coverage. Amica is cheapest for liability only in Quadrant data at $62 a month but third for full coverage in MoneyGeek data at $102, and Travelers is cheapest for full coverage in ValuePenguin data at $196 but third for liability only in Quadrant data at $81. The carrier that wins one coverage level can lose the other by a wide margin.
Bundle home and auto where it helps. Amica offers a bundling discount of up to 30 percent, and it pays policyholder dividends of up to 20 percent on some policies. A Rhode Island homeowner who bundles with Amica can see a lower combined bill than the standalone auto rate suggests, which is why the cheapest auto-only quote is not always the cheapest total. The matching home side is worth checking: homeowners insurance in Rhode Island averages $2,412 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage, and Amica is cheapest there in three datasets.
Key takeaways
USAA is the cheapest car insurance in Rhode Island at $80 a month for liability only and $123 a month for full coverage, but only military members and their families can buy it. Among carriers open to everyone, Quincy is cheapest in MoneyGeek data at $85 a month for full coverage, State Farm is cheapest in Insurify data at $159, and Travelers is cheapest in ValuePenguin data at $196. Amica is cheapest for liability only in Quadrant data at $62 a month, Travelers is cheapest for full coverage in 84 percent of Rhode Island cities, and the state average of $295 a month for full coverage is the second highest in the country. The gap between the cheapest and the most expensive quote for the same driver can run past $200 a month, so quoting four carriers is worth more in Rhode Island than in almost any other state.
Rhode Island drivers who want the full average behind the cheapest ranking can read how much car insurance costs in Rhode Island, which is the companion post to this one. The cheapest-company ranking for other states is in cheapest car insurance in New Hampshire and cheapest car insurance in California, and the Connecticut comparison is car insurance in Connecticut. The dataset behind the cheapest table is ValuePenguin’s cheapest car insurance in Rhode Island page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest car insurance in Rhode Island?
USAA is cheapest at $80 a month for liability only and $123 a month for full coverage, but only military members and their families can buy it. Among carriers open to everyone, Quincy is cheapest in MoneyGeek data at $85 a month for full coverage, State Farm is cheapest in Insurify data at $159, and Travelers is cheapest in ValuePenguin data at $196.
How much is car insurance in Rhode Island per month?
Full coverage averages $295 a month, or $3,544 a year, according to Insurify data updated November 18, 2026. Minimum coverage averages $178 a month. The cheapest full coverage quote in the state is $85 a month from Quincy, and the five-company average is $248 a month in Quadrant data.
Is Amica cheap for car insurance in Rhode Island?
Amica is cheapest for liability only in Quadrant data at $62 a month, and it ranks first overall in Rhode Island in MoneyGeek’s analysis with a 4.79 out of 5 score. Its full coverage averages $102 a month in MoneyGeek data but $306 a month in ValuePenguin data, so it is cheap for some drivers and expensive for others. It offers bundling discounts of up to 30 percent and dividends of up to 20 percent.
What is the minimum car insurance required in Rhode Island?
Rhode Island requires 25/50/25 liability coverage: $25,000 bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident, and $25,000 property damage. A combined single limit of $75,000 is an accepted alternative. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage must be included unless the driver rejects it in writing.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Rhode Island for a teen driver?
Teen drivers average $457 a month overall in Rhode Island in Insurify data, nearly double the $250 average for drivers in their 40s. No dataset publishes a teen-specific cheapest carrier for Rhode Island, so a parent should quote Travelers, Progressive, and Amica for the teen and add the teen to a family policy rather than buying a standalone one.
Does Quincy Insurance sell car insurance outside Rhode Island?
Quincy Insurance is a regional carrier focused on New England, and it is cheapest for full coverage in Rhode Island in MoneyGeek’s analysis at $85 a month. It does not appear in the Insurify or ValuePenguin cheapest tables for Rhode Island, which is why a driver who only checks national comparison sites can miss it entirely.