Car Insurance

Cheapest Car Insurance in New Jersey in 2026: Lowest Rates by Company and City

The cheapest car insurance in New Jersey is NJM at $111 a month for liability only and $136 a month for full coverage, per Insurify. MoneyGeek ties NJM and Selective at $123 a month for full coverage, the state minimum rose to 35/70/25 on January 1, 2026, and rates rose 20 percent in 2025.

On this page

The cheapest car insurance in New Jersey is NJM, at $111 a month for liability only and $136 a month for full coverage, according to Insurify data updated November 18, 2026. MoneyGeek agrees on the company but prices it lower, at $78 a month for minimum coverage and $123 a month for full coverage, tied with Selective. ValuePenguin disagrees and names GEICO cheapest, at $66 a month for liability only and $141 a month for full coverage.

Three datasets, three different winners, and the gap between the cheapest and the most expensive quote for the same driver can run past $150 a month. New Jersey is one of the most expensive states for car insurance, with a full coverage average of $257 a month per Insurify, and rates rose 20 percent in 2025, the largest increase in the nation. In a state this expensive, the carrier choice is worth more than in almost any other. This post compares every dataset, breaks the cheapest rate down by driver type and city, and explains the new minimums that took effect on January 1, 2026.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey?

NJM has the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey for most drivers, at $111 a month for liability only and $136 a month for full coverage in Insurify data. NJM, short for New Jersey Manufacturers, is a regional carrier that writes most of its business in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, and it pairs the lowest rate in the Insurify table with the highest J.D. Power score in the Mid-Atlantic region, at 721. That combination of cheapest price and best service is rare in any state.

MoneyGeek puts NJM and Selective in a tie for cheapest full coverage at $123 a month, with Plymouth Rock at $143, Travelers at $144, and Farmers at $150. For minimum coverage, MoneyGeek names Selective cheapest at $68 a month, with GEICO at $71, NJM and Plymouth Rock tied at $78, and Amica at $92. ValuePenguin names GEICO cheapest for both coverages, at $66 a month for liability only and $141 a month for full coverage, with NJM second for full coverage at $168 and Plymouth Rock second for liability only at $85.

The disagreement comes from different driver profiles and different company sets. ValuePenguin analyzed 146,016 quotes from nine leading companies. MoneyGeek prices its own standard profile and includes Selective, which ValuePenguin does not rank in its cheapest table. Insurify averages real-time quotes from its partner network. A driver should quote NJM, GEICO, Plymouth Rock, and Selective, because those four cover the winner in every dataset.

Cheapest full coverage in New Jersey, by dataset

Company Insurify ValuePenguin MoneyGeek
NJM $136/month $168/month $123/month
GEICO $276/month $141/month Not in top five
Selective Not listed Not listed $123/month
Plymouth Rock $206/month $178/month $143/month
Travelers Not listed $259/month $144/month
Progressive $273/month $233/month Not in top five
AAA $239/month Not listed Not listed
Mercury $309/month Not listed Not listed

GEICO shows the widest spread of any carrier in the table: $141 a month in ValuePenguin data and $276 a month in Insurify data. That is not a typo. The two datasets price different drivers, and GEICO’s pricing varies more by profile than most carriers. A driver who reads only one dataset can conclude GEICO is either the cheapest or one of the most expensive companies in the state, and both conclusions are supported by real data.

MoneyGeek’s full coverage state average is $172 a month, against a national average of $123, while Insurify puts the New Jersey full coverage average at $257 a month. The two averages differ by $85 a month because the profiles differ, but both agree New Jersey is expensive: MoneyGeek’s figure is $49 a month above the national average, and Insurify’s is higher still. The cheapest full coverage quote in the state, NJM at $123 a month, sits $51 a month below MoneyGeek’s state average, or about $612 a year.

Cheapest minimum coverage in New Jersey

Minimum coverage is where the new 2026 limits bite hardest. New Jersey raised its minimums on January 1, 2026, from 25/50/25 to 35/70/25 plus $15,000 of personal injury protection: $35,000 bodily injury per person, $70,000 per accident, and $25,000 property damage. Every minimum rate below is priced at those new limits, so a quote from before January 2026 is not comparable.

Company Insurify ValuePenguin MoneyGeek
NJM $111/month $92/month $78/month
Selective Not listed Not listed $68/month
GEICO $216/month $66/month $71/month
Plymouth Rock $132/month $85/month $78/month
CSAA $156/month Not listed Not listed
Allstate $169/month Not listed Not listed
Amica Not listed Not listed $92/month

The step from minimum to full coverage at NJM costs $25 a month in Insurify data: full coverage is $136 against $111 for liability only, or $300 a year. In MoneyGeek data the step is larger, $123 against $78, or $45 a month, $540 a year. Either way, the step buys collision and comprehensive coverage for the driver’s own car, which minimum coverage does not include at all.

Every standard New Jersey policy must also carry uninsured motorist coverage at the same amounts as the liability coverage, so the January 2026 minimums set the floor for uninsured motorist coverage too. New Jersey is a choice no-fault state, which means a driver chooses between a standard policy with the right to sue for pain and suffering and a basic policy with limited lawsuit rights. The basic policy is cheaper, but the savings come with a real legal trade-off that a driver should understand before choosing it.

Cheapest car insurance in New Jersey by driver type

NJM wins more driver categories in New Jersey than any other carrier. MoneyGeek finds NJM cheapest for teen drivers at $326 a month for a 16-year-old girl and $341 for a 16-year-old boy on a family policy, cheapest for seniors at $122 a month, cheapest after an at-fault accident at $133 a month, and cheapest after a DUI at $149 a month, only $26 above its clean rate of $123. ValuePenguin finds NJM cheapest after an accident at $183 a month and cheapest for drivers with poor credit at $288 a month.

Driver type Cheapest company Monthly rate Dataset
Teen, age 16, female NJM $326 MoneyGeek
Teen, age 16, male NJM $341 MoneyGeek
Senior driver NJM $122 MoneyGeek
After a speeding ticket Selective $123 MoneyGeek
After a speeding ticket Plymouth Rock $178 ValuePenguin
After an at-fault accident NJM $133 MoneyGeek
After an at-fault accident NJM $183 ValuePenguin
After a DUI NJM $149 MoneyGeek
Poor credit NJM $288 ValuePenguin
Bad credit Travelers $176 MoneyGeek

The one category where NJM does not win is a speeding ticket, where the two datasets disagree with each other. MoneyGeek names Selective cheapest at $123 a month, and ValuePenguin names Plymouth Rock cheapest at $178 a month. Full coverage rates rise by an average of 29 percent after a first speeding ticket in New Jersey, and 73 percent after an at-fault accident, according to ValuePenguin, so the ticket itself matters more than the carrier. A driver with a ticket should re-shop immediately, because the ranking reshuffles completely after a violation.

NJM lists three discounts that apply to teen drivers in New Jersey: a driver training discount, a defensive driving discount on liability, PIP, and collision for state-approved courses, and a good student discount for a 3.0 GPA or honor roll. Its one limitation is that it does not sell accident forgiveness in New Jersey, while Selective does, and Selective also offers gap insurance, new car replacement, and a rideshare endorsement. A driver choosing between the two cheapest carriers is choosing between NJM’s lower claim dispute rate and Selective’s wider add-on menu.

Cheapest car insurance by New Jersey city

GEICO has the cheapest full coverage insurance in nearly all cities and towns across New Jersey, including Newark and Jersey City, according to ValuePenguin, with Erie cheapest in the remaining 2 percent of cities. That finding sits oddly next to MoneyGeek’s note that Plymouth Rock is cheapest for minimum coverage in 19 of New Jersey’s 20 largest cities. The two findings are compatible: GEICO wins full coverage, Plymouth Rock wins minimum coverage, and the winner depends on what the driver buys.

Newark is the most expensive large city in the state. MoneyGeek puts Newark at $248 a month for full coverage against $191 in Trenton, and ValuePenguin’s city table shows the same pattern at a lower level. New Jersey rates vary by ZIP code more than most states, and the spread inside a single city can be larger than the spread between cities. A driver in Newark who quotes only one carrier can pay hundreds of dollars a year more than a neighbor with the same car and the same record.

Why New Jersey is so expensive, and what to do about it

New Jersey rates rose 20 percent in 2025, the largest increase in the nation, according to Insurify, and the data scientists there project a further 1 percent increase by the end of 2026. The state has about 30 insurance groups writing private passenger auto insurance, so competition exists, but the underlying costs are high: dense traffic, high repair costs, expensive medical claims under the PIP system, and a litigious claims environment.

The practical response is to quote widely and to check the coverage level before the price. A $111 a month liability-only quote from NJM and a $66 a month minimum quote from GEICO are not the same product at different prices: they are different coverage levels priced for different drivers in different datasets. The comparison only works when the limits, deductibles, and driver profile are identical. A driver who compares the same 35/70/25 minimum at four carriers, then the same full coverage at four carriers, will find the cheapest option for their actual situation instead of the cheapest headline in a table.

Key takeaways

NJM is the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey for most drivers at $111 a month for liability only and $136 a month for full coverage in Insurify data, and it wins the teen, senior, accident, DUI, and poor credit categories too. MoneyGeek ties NJM and Selective for cheapest full coverage at $123 a month, with Selective cheapest for minimum coverage at $68, and ValuePenguin names GEICO cheapest at $66 for liability only and $141 for full coverage. The state minimum rose to 35/70/25 plus $15,000 PIP on January 1, 2026, rates rose 20 percent in 2025, and GEICO is cheapest for full coverage in nearly every city while Plymouth Rock is cheapest for minimum coverage in 19 of the 20 largest cities.

New Jersey drivers who want the full average behind the cheapest ranking can read how much car insurance costs in New Jersey, and homeowners can compare with homeowners insurance in New Jersey. The cheapest-company ranking for other states is in cheapest car insurance in California and cheapest car insurance in New Hampshire, and the Oregon comparison is car insurance in Oregon. The dataset behind the cheapest table is Insurify’s cheapest car insurance in New Jersey page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey?

NJM is cheapest for most drivers at $111 a month for liability only and $136 a month for full coverage, according to Insurify. MoneyGeek ties NJM and Selective at $123 a month for full coverage, and ValuePenguin names GEICO cheapest at $66 a month for liability only and $141 a month for full coverage. Quote all four, because the winner depends on the driver.

How much is car insurance in New Jersey per month?

Full coverage averages $257 a month in New Jersey, according to Insurify data updated November 17, 2026, and minimum coverage averages $181 a month. MoneyGeek puts the full coverage state average lower at $172 a month. Rates rose 20 percent in 2025, the largest increase in the nation.

What is the minimum car insurance required in New Jersey in 2026?

New Jersey requires 35/70/25 liability coverage plus $15,000 of personal injury protection since January 1, 2026: $35,000 bodily injury per person, $70,000 per accident, and $25,000 property damage. The previous minimum was 25/50/25. Uninsured motorist coverage is required at the same amounts.

Is NJM good car insurance?

NJM pairs the lowest rate in the Insurify table with the highest J.D. Power score in the Mid-Atlantic region, at 721, and it includes rental car reimbursement automatically, an add-on other carriers usually charge for. It does not sell accident forgiveness in New Jersey, and it is cheapest for teens, seniors, and drivers with an accident or a DUI on their record.

What is the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey for a teen driver?

NJM is cheapest for teen drivers at $326 a month for a 16-year-old girl and $341 for a 16-year-old boy on a family policy, in MoneyGeek data. NJM offers a driver training discount, a defensive driving discount, and a good student discount for a 3.0 GPA or honor roll.

Which New Jersey city has the cheapest car insurance?

GEICO has the cheapest full coverage in nearly all New Jersey cities, including Newark and Jersey City, according to ValuePenguin. Plymouth Rock is cheapest for minimum coverage in 19 of the 20 largest cities, according to MoneyGeek. Newark is the most expensive large city at $248 a month for full coverage, against $191 in Trenton.