Car Insurance

Cheapest Car Insurance in Wyoming in 2026: Lowest Rates by Company and City

American National offers the cheapest car insurance in Wyoming in 2026 at $70 a month for full coverage and $19 a month for minimum coverage. GEICO is cheapest for teens at $211 a month, Progressive is cheapest for full coverage in Cheyenne at $115 a month, and credit matters more than the carrier.

On this page

The cheapest car insurance in Wyoming is American National, at $70 a month for full coverage and $19 a month for minimum coverage, according to MoneyGeek. USAA is cheaper still, at $46 a month for full coverage, but only military members, veterans, and their families can buy it. The catch is that the cheapest carrier changes with the driver, the city, and the coverage level, so the right answer for a 40 year old in Cheyenne is not the right answer for a teen in Laramie. This post compares the cheapest options by company, by driver type, and by city, using the same datasets side by side.

Every figure below names its source, because the datasets disagree and the disagreement matters. MoneyGeek prices a 40 year old man in a 2012 Toyota Camry with a clean record and good credit, using Quadrant Information Services rate filings. Insurify averages real quotes from drivers aged 20 to 70 with clean records. InsuranceQuotes prices a 40 year old driver with a clean record using rates insurers filed with state regulators. The Zebra averages quotes from its own customers. A carrier that is cheapest in one dataset can rank second or third in another, and the tables below show that rather than hiding it.

Cheapest car insurance in Wyoming by coverage level

For minimum coverage, American National is cheapest at $19 a month, according to MoneyGeek. USAA is cheaper in Insurify data at $27 a month for liability only, but it is limited to military households. State Farm is next at $29 a month in Insurify data, and GEICO at $41. For full coverage, American National is cheapest at $70 a month in MoneyGeek data, USAA at $46 a month in Insurify data for eligible households, and State Farm at $51 a month.

Coverage level Cheapest carrier Rate per month Source
Minimum coverage American National $19 MoneyGeek
Minimum coverage GEICO $14 The Zebra
Minimum coverage USAA, military only $27 Insurify
Full coverage American National $70 MoneyGeek
Full coverage USAA, military only $46 Insurify
Full coverage GEICO $85 The Zebra

The table looks contradictory until the sources are named. The $19 minimum and $70 full coverage figures are MoneyGeek, pricing one driver profile. The $14 minimum and $85 full coverage figures are The Zebra, averaging its own customers, and The Zebra names GEICO as cheapest for both levels in its data. The $46 and $27 figures are Insurify, averaging real quotes. No single carrier is cheapest in every dataset, but American National wins the full coverage ranking in two of the three, and GEICO wins the minimum coverage ranking in The Zebra data. A Wyoming driver who only checks one source can miss the carrier that is actually cheapest for their profile.

The gap between minimum and full coverage is the price of protecting your own car. At American National, full coverage costs $51 a month more than minimum coverage, or $612 a year extra, according to MoneyGeek. That $612 buys collision and comprehensive coverage, which pay for damage to your own car in a crash you cause, and for hail, theft, and deer strikes. Wyoming drivers who drop to minimum coverage to save money should know what they are giving up: a liability only policy pays nothing toward their own car, no matter what happens to it.

Cheapest car insurance companies in Wyoming compared

American National is cheapest overall in MoneyGeek data, and Insure.com agrees, pricing American National at $1,271 a year for full coverage with 100/300/100 limits and $500 deductibles, the lowest in its study. State Farm is the strongest all around choice in MoneyGeek’s review, with full coverage at $72 a month and the highest J.D. Power score among the top five Wyoming carriers, at 648. GEICO is the cheapest option among the top five in the same review, at $65 a month for full coverage.

Company Full coverage per month Minimum per month Source
American National $70 $19 MoneyGeek
USAA, military only $46 $27 Insurify
State Farm $51 $29 Insurify
GEICO $65 $52 MoneyGeek best car review
State Farm $72 Not published MoneyGeek best car review
Safeco $74 Not published InsuranceQuotes
GEICO $78 $41 Insurify
Progressive $78 Not published MoneyGeek best car review
Travelers $80 Not published MoneyGeek best car review
Allstate $86 Not published MoneyGeek best car review
Allstate $249 Not published InsuranceQuotes

Allstate shows up twice in the table, at $86 a month in one dataset and $249 in another, and the gap is a useful warning about taking any single figure as gospel. MoneyGeek prices Allstate for a 40 year old man in a 2012 Camry with good credit, while InsuranceQuotes prices a 40 year old driver with a clean record using filed rates across five insurers, and the two samples land very differently for Allstate. The carrier spread is real either way: full coverage in Wyoming runs from $70 to $130 a month across the major carriers in MoneyGeek data, and from $74 to $249 a month in InsuranceQuotes data. A driver who takes the first quote can pay double what the cheapest carrier charges.

Cheapest car insurance in Wyoming by driver type

The cheapest carrier changes with the driver, and the differences are large enough to matter. A teen driver, a senior, and a driver with poor credit each have a different cheapest carrier in Wyoming, and the carrier that is cheapest for a 40 year old with good credit is rarely cheapest for the others.

Driver type Cheapest carrier Full coverage per month
Standard driver, good credit American National $70
Teen driver, female, age 16 GEICO $211
Teen driver, male, age 16 GEICO $250
Senior driver American National $72
Driver with poor credit American National $248
Military household USAA $46

GEICO has the cheapest rate for a 16 year old in Wyoming, at $211 a month for a female driver and $250 for a male driver with full coverage added onto a family policy, according to MoneyGeek. American National has the cheapest rate for seniors, at $72 a month for full coverage, $5 below State Farm at $77. Progressive is the most practical option for Wyoming drivers carrying a DWUI or at fault accident on their record, according to MoneyGeek, with full coverage at $78 a month, close to the state average.

Credit is the single biggest price lever in Wyoming. American National charges $70 a month for a driver with good credit and $248 a month for the same driver with poor credit, according to MoneyGeek, a $2,136 a year difference for the same car and the same coverage. That gap is larger than the gap between the cheapest and most expensive carriers, which means a driver with poor credit should shop harder than a driver with good credit, because the savings from finding the right carrier are bigger. Improving a credit score is the cheapest long term way to cut a Wyoming car insurance bill, and our guide to how credit scores affect insurance premiums explains how much a lower score can add.

Cheapest car insurance by city in Wyoming

Cheyenne, the capital and biggest city, averages $141 a month for full coverage and $62 a month for liability only, according to Insurify, which is well above the statewide averages of $94 and $50 a month. Safeco offers the cheapest liability only coverage in Cheyenne, at $42 a month. Progressive offers the cheapest full coverage among carriers open to everyone, at $115 a month. USAA averages $65 a month for full coverage in Cheyenne for eligible military households, State Farm $72, GEICO $109, Farmers $111, and Safeco $126.

The city ranking and the statewide ranking are different lists. American National is cheapest statewide, but it does not show up in the Cheyenne top five, while Progressive, which is not cheapest statewide, is cheapest for full coverage in Cheyenne. A driver who shops from the statewide ranking alone can miss the carrier that is actually cheapest in their own city. The only number that matters is the quote for your own ZIP code, and the city table is a starting point for which carriers to include in that quote.

Why the cheapest carrier keeps changing

The cheapest carrier changes because every carrier prices risk differently. American National prices the standard 40 year old driver lowest. GEICO prices teens and minimum coverage lowest. Progressive prices drivers with a DWUI or at fault accident most competitively. State Farm prices the combination of low rates and strong claims service best. A carrier that is cheapest for one driver can be the most expensive for another, and the only way to find the cheapest carrier for your own profile is to get quotes from several of them.

The coverage level changes the ranking too. A carrier that is cheapest for minimum coverage is not always cheapest for full coverage, because collision and comprehensive coverage are priced on the car as well as the driver. A carrier that prices liability cheaply can price collision expensively, and the full coverage ranking is the one that matters for a driver who wants their own car protected. Compare the same coverage limits and deductibles across every quote, because a cheap quote with low limits is not the same product as a cheap quote with high limits.

The city changes the ranking as well. Cheyenne averages $141 a month for full coverage against a statewide average of $94, according to Insurify, and the cheapest carrier in Cheyenne is Progressive, not American National. Rural ZIP codes price lower than city ZIP codes, and a driver who moves from Cheyenne to Laramie can see the premium fall without changing carriers. The statewide cheapest list is a starting point, and the ZIP code quote is the answer.

How to get the cheapest car insurance rate in Wyoming

Start by getting quotes from at least three companies, and include American National, State Farm, and GEICO, since one of the three is cheapest for most Wyoming driver profiles. USAA is worth a quote if anyone in the household is eligible. Compare the same coverage limits and deductibles across every quote, and check the minimums guide before deciding how much coverage to carry: our minimum car insurance by state guide explains what every state requires and why the minimum is rarely enough.

Raise the deductible if you can afford it. A driver who moves from a $500 deductible to a $1,000 deductible usually saves a noticeable amount each month, and the savings add up over a year. Bundling home and auto with the same carrier also helps, and our Wyoming homeowners insurance guide shows what the home side of a bundle costs. Ask about safe driver, good student, and defensive driving discounts by name, since carriers do not always apply them without being asked. Paying the premium in full instead of monthly can also cut the cost, since some carriers charge a fee for monthly billing.

Re-shop the policy every year. Wyoming rates are projected to rise about 2 percent by the end of 2026, according to Insurify, but the cheapest carrier for your profile can change faster than the state average moves. A carrier that was cheapest last year can raise its rates while a competitor holds theirs, and the only way to catch the change is a fresh set of quotes. For the full picture of what Wyoming car insurance costs, see our how much is car insurance in Wyoming guide, and for comparison with neighboring states, see our cheapest car insurance in South Dakota guide and our cheapest car insurance in Kansas guide.

What to remember about the cheapest car insurance in Wyoming

American National is cheapest for most Wyoming drivers at $70 a month for full coverage and $19 a month for minimum coverage, according to MoneyGeek, and USAA is cheaper still at $46 a month for military households. GEICO is cheapest for teens and for minimum coverage in The Zebra data, Progressive is cheapest for full coverage in Cheyenne, and the gap between the cheapest and most expensive quote for the same driver runs past $2,000 a year. Credit is the biggest price lever: the same driver pays $70 a month with good credit and $248 with poor credit at the same company. Get three quotes, compare the same limits, and re-shop every year.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest car insurance in Wyoming?

American National offers the cheapest car insurance in Wyoming for most drivers, at $70 a month for full coverage and $19 a month for minimum coverage, according to MoneyGeek. USAA is cheaper at $46 a month for full coverage, but only military members, veterans, and their families can buy it.

What is the cheapest full coverage car insurance in Wyoming?

American National offers the cheapest full coverage car insurance in Wyoming, at $70 a month, according to MoneyGeek. Insure.com agrees, pricing American National at $1,271 a year for full coverage with 100/300/100 limits and $500 deductibles.

What is the cheapest car insurance in Cheyenne, WY?

Progressive offers the cheapest full coverage in Cheyenne among carriers open to everyone, at $115 a month, according to Insurify. Safeco offers the cheapest liability only coverage in Cheyenne, at $42 a month. USAA averages $65 a month for full coverage in Cheyenne for eligible military households.

What is the cheapest car insurance for teens in Wyoming?

GEICO offers the cheapest car insurance for teens in Wyoming, at $211 a month for a 16 year old female driver and $250 a month for a 16 year old male driver with full coverage added onto a family policy, according to MoneyGeek.

What is the cheapest car insurance for seniors in Wyoming?

American National offers the cheapest car insurance for seniors in Wyoming, at $72 a month for full coverage, according to MoneyGeek. State Farm is next at $77 a month.

How can I lower my car insurance in Wyoming?

Get quotes from at least three carriers, raise the deductible if you can afford it, bundle home and auto, and ask about safe driver and good student discounts by name. Improving a credit score is the cheapest long term way to cut the bill, since the same driver pays $70 a month with good credit and $248 with poor credit at American National.

MoneyGeek publishes its Wyoming figures in its cheapest car insurance in Wyoming guide, built from Quadrant Information Services rate filings. Insurify publishes its Wyoming figures in its cheapest car insurance quotes in Wyoming guide, updated November 13, 2026. For the full picture of what Wyoming car insurance costs, see our how much is car insurance in Wyoming guide.