Car Insurance

Cheapest Car Insurance in South Dakota in 2026: Lowest Rates by Company and City

Progressive and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska offer the cheapest car insurance in South Dakota in 2026, and the two are effectively tied. Progressive is cheapest for full coverage at $1,096 a year and for seniors at $55 a month, Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is cheapest for teens at $140 a month, and Watertown has the cheapest city rates.

On this page

The cheapest car insurance in South Dakota comes from Progressive and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska, and the two are effectively tied. Progressive averages $1,096 a year for full coverage, according to NerdWallet, and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska averages about $138 a month in the InsuranceQuotes table. Which one is cheapest for you depends on your age, your driving record, and how much coverage you buy. This post compares the cheapest carriers by driver type, by company, and by city, and explains why the winner changes with the profile.

South Dakota is a cheap state for car insurance in every dataset that publishes a national comparison. Full coverage averages $2,329 a year, or $194 a month, according to InsuranceQuotes, which is 17 percent below the United States average. The cheapest carriers price at roughly half the state average. The gap between the cheapest carrier and the state average is about $700 to $1,100 a year, and that gap is the whole reason to shop.

Cheapest car insurance in South Dakota by driver type

The cheapest carrier in South Dakota changes with the driver. MoneyGeek, pricing a 40 year old driver with a clean record and good credit, names Progressive cheapest for full coverage at $65 a month and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska cheapest for minimum coverage at $15 a month. ValuePenguin, pricing a 30 year old man, names Farmers Mutual of Nebraska cheapest for full coverage at $95 a month and Progressive cheapest for minimum coverage at $16 a month. The two studies agree on the shortlist and disagree on the winner, because they price different drivers.

Driver type Cheapest carrier Rate per month Source
Full coverage, most drivers Progressive $65 MoneyGeek
Full coverage, 30 year old Farmers Mutual of Nebraska $95 ValuePenguin
Minimum coverage, most drivers Farmers Mutual of Nebraska $15 MoneyGeek
Minimum coverage, 30 year old Progressive $16 ValuePenguin
Teen drivers Farmers Mutual of Nebraska $140 MoneyGeek
Young drivers Farmers Mutual of Nebraska $46 ValuePenguin
Senior drivers Progressive $55 MoneyGeek

The teen and young driver rows need a note, because the two figures look contradictory and are not. MoneyGeek prices teen drivers, ages 16 to 19, and names Farmers Mutual of Nebraska cheapest at $140 a month. ValuePenguin prices young drivers at a different age band and names Farmers Mutual of Nebraska cheapest at $46 a month. Both name the same carrier, and the price difference is the age band, not a disagreement. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is the cheapest insurer for teens and young drivers across the entire 16 to 25 age range, according to MoneyGeek.

For senior drivers, Progressive is cheapest at $55 a month, according to MoneyGeek, $4 less than Farmers Mutual of Nebraska at $59. For military members, veterans, and their families, USAA beats both, at $75 a month for full coverage in the ValuePenguin table and $131 a month in the InsuranceQuotes table. The two USAA figures differ because the studies price different drivers, and USAA is only available to military affiliated drivers either way.

Cheapest car insurance companies in South Dakota compared

Five datasets publish cheapest carrier tables for South Dakota, and all five name Progressive or Farmers Mutual of Nebraska as the cheapest for full coverage. The table below puts the two most detailed studies side by side so the profile difference is visible.

Company Full coverage per month, InsuranceQuotes, 40 year old Full coverage per month, ValuePenguin, 30 year old Minimum coverage per month, ValuePenguin
Farmers Mutual of Nebraska $138 $95 $17
Progressive $140 $131 $16
USAA, military only $131 $75 Not published
State Farm $183 $155 Not published
Allstate $190 Not published Not published
Nationwide $196 $211 Not published
GEICO $207 Not published Not published
North Star Mutual $238 Not published Not published
American Family $272 Not published Not published

Progressive’s cheapest full coverage ranges from $65 a month in the MoneyGeek table to $160 a month in the MarketWatch table, which prices a 35 year old driver with a 2023 Toyota Camry across 212 South Dakota ZIP codes. The rank holds across all five datasets, and the number moves with the profile. That is the single most important thing to understand about cheapest carrier lists: the winner is stable, the price is not.

MarketWatch names Progressive the cheapest overall auto insurance company in South Dakota, with minimum coverage at $23 a month and full coverage at $160 a month, using April 2026 Quadrant data. Its state averages are $51 a month for minimum coverage and $238 a month for full coverage, higher than the other datasets because it prices a younger driver and a newer car. NerdWallet names Progressive cheapest at $1,096 a year, or $91 a month, for a 2023 Toyota Camry LE, and puts the state average at $2,237 a year.

GEICO is the most expensive of the five carriers MoneyGeek compared, at $103 a month for full coverage, $456 a year more than Progressive for the same protection. American Family is the most expensive in the InsuranceQuotes table at $272 a month, nearly double the Farmers Mutual of Nebraska rate. A driver who renews with the most expensive carrier instead of the cheapest can pay $1,000 or more a year extra for the same coverage.

Cheapest car insurance in South Dakota by city

Watertown has the cheapest car insurance rates in South Dakota, with drivers paying an average of $161 a month for full coverage, according to ValuePenguin. Brookings is cheapest in the MoneyGeek table at $86 a month for full coverage, and Rapid City is most expensive at $119 a month. The two studies price different drivers, so the city ranking differs, but both agree the spread across cities is about $30 a month.

City Cheapest full coverage per month Cheapest carrier Source
Brookings $86 Not published MoneyGeek
Watertown $161 Not published ValuePenguin
Rapid City $119 Not published MoneyGeek

For minimum coverage, Brookings, Madison, and Watertown share the cheapest rates in the state at $11 a month with Progressive, according to MoneyGeek. MarketWatch publishes the widest city table, with cheapest minimum coverage by city ranging from $12 a month in Bison and Lake Preston to $22 a month in Aberdeen, all with Progressive or Farmers. The cheapest carrier by city is almost always Progressive or Farmers, and the cheapest city is almost always a small town rather than Sioux Falls or Rapid City.

Why the cheapest carrier changes with the profile

Every carrier prices risk differently. Progressive prices young drivers and seniors aggressively in South Dakota, which is why it wins both of those bands in the MoneyGeek table. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska prices teens aggressively, which is why it wins the 16 to 25 band. State Farm prices liability only competitively in some datasets and full coverage less so, which is why it appears as cheapest for minimum coverage in other states but not in South Dakota.

Credit matters too. South Dakota allows insurers to use credit based insurance scores, and a poor credit history can raise the premium substantially. A driver with poor credit should get quotes from the same cheapest carriers, because the ranking can change: a carrier that is cheapest for a good credit driver is not always cheapest for a poor credit driver. No South Dakota specific cheapest carrier for poor credit drivers is published in the datasets used here, and this post does not fill that gap with national figures.

Coverage level matters as well. Progressive is cheapest for full coverage and for minimum coverage, but the two are different products. Minimum coverage at 25/50/25 costs $16 a month with Progressive, while full coverage costs $65 to $140 a month depending on the study. A driver who buys minimum coverage to save money should understand what it does not cover: nothing for their own car after a crash, a deer strike, or a hailstorm.

A worked example: the cheapest quote against the state average

Take a 40 year old driver with a clean record. The state average for full coverage is $2,329 a year, according to InsuranceQuotes. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska averages $138 a month, or $1,656 a year, a saving of $673 a year. In the NerdWallet table, Progressive averages $1,096 a year against a state average of $2,237, a saving of $1,141 a year. In the MoneyGeek table, Progressive averages $65 a month, or $780 a year, against a state average of $106 a month, or $1,272 a year, a saving of $492 a year. The saving is between $492 and $1,141 a year depending on the dataset, and every dataset agrees the saving is large.

How to get the cheapest car insurance in South Dakota

Get quotes from Progressive and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska first, then add State Farm and one more carrier for comparison. Compare the same coverage limits and the same deductible on every quote. A $500 deductible quote is not comparable to a $1,000 deductible quote, and 50/100/50 liability is not comparable to 100/300/100.

Ask about discounts for bundling home and auto, a clean driving record, a car with safety features, paying the premium in full, and a telematics program that tracks driving. Check whether the carrier offers accident forgiveness and whether it costs extra. If you drive less than 7,500 miles a year, ask about a low mileage discount. Our guide to how much car insurance costs in South Dakota has the full dataset comparison behind these cheapest figures, and our guide to how much car insurance costs per year puts the South Dakota numbers in a national frame. For comparison with neighboring states, see our cheapest car insurance in Kansas, our cheapest car insurance in Minnesota, and our Missouri car insurance guide.

What to remember about the cheapest car insurance in South Dakota

Progressive and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska are the cheapest car insurance carriers in South Dakota in every dataset, and the two are effectively tied. Progressive is cheapest for full coverage at $1,096 a year, Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is cheapest for teens at $140 a month, and Progressive is cheapest for minimum coverage at $16 a month. Watertown has the cheapest city rates, and the cheapest carrier is worth $492 to $1,141 a year against the state average. The winner changes with the driver, so get three quotes and compare the same coverage.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest car insurance in South Dakota?

Progressive and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska offer the cheapest car insurance in South Dakota, and the two are effectively tied. Progressive averages $1,096 a year for full coverage, according to NerdWallet, and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska averages about $138 a month, according to InsuranceQuotes.

Who has the cheapest full coverage car insurance in South Dakota?

Progressive has the cheapest full coverage car insurance in South Dakota, with an average rate of $1,096 a year, according to NerdWallet. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is effectively tied at about $138 a month in the InsuranceQuotes table, and ValuePenguin names Farmers Mutual of Nebraska cheapest at $95 a month for a 30 year old driver.

What is the cheapest minimum coverage car insurance in South Dakota?

Progressive offers the cheapest minimum liability car insurance in South Dakota at $16 a month, according to both InsuranceQuotes and ValuePenguin. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is next at $17 a month in the ValuePenguin table.

What is the cheapest car insurance in South Dakota for teens?

Farmers Mutual of Nebraska has the cheapest car insurance for teens in South Dakota at $140 a month, according to MoneyGeek. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is the cheapest insurer for teens and young drivers across the entire 16 to 25 age range.

What is the cheapest car insurance in South Dakota for seniors?

Progressive has the cheapest car insurance for seniors in South Dakota at $55 a month, according to MoneyGeek. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is next at $59 a month.

How much is the cheapest car insurance in Watertown, SD?

Watertown has the cheapest car insurance rates in South Dakota, with drivers paying an average of $161 a month for full coverage, according to ValuePenguin. Brookings is cheapest in the MoneyGeek table at $86 a month for the same coverage, priced for a different driver profile.

InsuranceQuotes publishes its South Dakota figures in its South Dakota car insurance cost and quotes page, with rates as of August 31, 2026, compiled by Quadrant Information Services from rates insurers filed with state regulators. NerdWallet publishes its South Dakota figures in its cheap car insurance in South Dakota guide, updated November 2026. MoneyGeek publishes its South Dakota figures in its cheapest car insurance in South Dakota guide. ValuePenguin publishes its South Dakota figures in its best cheap auto insurance in South Dakota guide.