Car Insurance

Cheapest Car Insurance in Idaho in 2026: Lowest Rates by Company and City

GEICO offers the cheapest car insurance in Idaho in 2026 at $53 a month for full coverage, and State Farm is cheapest for minimum coverage at $18 a month. Travelers is cheapest at $808 a year in NerdWallet data, Grange leads for poor credit at $139 a month, and GEICO is cheapest in Boise at $54 a month.

On this page

The cheapest car insurance in Idaho in 2026 depends on which study you read. GEICO is cheapest for full coverage at $53 a month, according to MoneyGeek. Travelers is cheapest at $808 a year, according to NerdWallet. State Farm is cheapest at $85 a month, according to ValuePenguin. Four studies, four different winners, and this post lays out what each one actually measured, who is cheapest for your driver type, and who is cheapest in your city.

The disagreement is the point, not a problem with the data. MoneyGeek prices a 40 year old driver with good credit in a 2012 Toyota Camry. NerdWallet prices a 35 year old driver with good credit in a 2023 Camry. ValuePenguin prices a different profile again. A newer car costs more to insure, so the 2023 Camry figures run higher by design. The rate that matters is the one carriers quote on your car and your record, and the way to find it is to quote three or four carriers yourself.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in Idaho in 2026?

GEICO has the cheapest full coverage in Idaho at $53 a month, according to MoneyGeek’s August 2026 study, with State Farm at $54 and American National at $57. NerdWallet’s August 2026 analysis names Travelers the cheapest at $808 a year, or $67 a month. ValuePenguin’s July 2026 study names State Farm the cheapest at $85 a month for full coverage and $26 a month for liability only. The three studies price different drivers, so all three winners are correct on their own basis.

Source Cheapest full coverage Cheapest minimum Test driver
MoneyGeek (Aug 2026) GEICO $53/mo State Farm $18/mo 40 year old, 2012 Camry
NerdWallet (Aug 2026) Travelers $808/yr American National $210/yr 35 year old, 2023 Camry
ValuePenguin (July 2026) State Farm $85/mo State Farm $26/mo liability Not published in summary
MoneyGeek cheapest companies (Aug 2026) GEICO $55/mo State Farm $18/mo National ranking table

MoneyGeek’s national cheapest companies table gives a second view of the same market: GEICO at $55 a month for full coverage in Idaho, or $656 a year, which is 34 percent below the national average, and State Farm at $18 a month for minimum coverage, or $210 a year, which is 52 percent below the national average. The $53 and $55 figures for GEICO come from two different MoneyGeek pages with different update dates, so treat the cheapest full coverage as a range of $53 to $55 a month, not a single exact figure.

The state average frames the savings. Full coverage in Idaho averages $79 a month in MoneyGeek’s study and $167 a month in NerdWallet’s, and minimum coverage averages $36 a month in both. A GEICO policy at $53 a month saves about $26 a month against the MoneyGeek average, or $312 a year, and the same driver paying the NerdWallet average would save more than $1,300 a year by switching to the cheapest quote.

Cheapest full coverage by company

MoneyGeek’s August 2026 company table prices the same 40 year old driver with good credit in a 2012 Camry across seven carriers. The spread between the cheapest and the most expensive is about $30 a month, or $360 a year, for identical coverage on the same car. That spread is larger than any city to city difference in the state, which means the company you pick matters more than where you live.

Company Full coverage per month Minimum per month Full coverage per year
State Farm $56 $18 $667
American National $56 $22 $668
GEICO $57 $25 $681
Grange $73 $24 $874
Farm Bureau $73 $27 $872
Auto-Owners $73 $33 $872
Travelers $86 $38 $1,029

One note on the source: this table shows GEICO at $57 a month for full coverage, while MoneyGeek’s Idaho calculator page names GEICO the cheapest at $53 a month. The two pages use different update dates and slightly different profiles. The ordering is consistent, and the three cheapest carriers are the same on both pages: GEICO, State Farm, and American National, all within $4 a month of each other. Travelers is the most expensive carrier in this table at $86 a month, even though NerdWallet names Travelers the cheapest for its own test driver. The winner changes with the driver, which is the whole argument for quoting several carriers.

Cheapest minimum coverage in Idaho

State Farm has the cheapest minimum coverage in Idaho at $18 a month, or $210 a year, according to MoneyGeek. American National is cheapest for minimum coverage at $210 a year in NerdWallet’s analysis, and ValuePenguin puts State Farm cheapest for liability only at $26 a month. The state minimum is 25/50/15: $25,000 in bodily injury liability per person, $50,000 per accident, and $15,000 in property damage liability.

Minimum coverage costs $434 a year on average, per NerdWallet, and $428 a year, per MoneyGeek, so the average and the cheapest are close together at the minimum level. The gap opens up at full coverage, where the average runs $952 to $1,999 a year and the cheapest quotes run $656 to $808. That is because minimum coverage is a commodity: every carrier sells the same $25,000/$50,000/$15,000 limits, so there is little room to differ. Full coverage adds collision, comprehensive, and higher liability limits, and carriers price those very differently.

The minimum is cheap, and it is also thin. It pays nothing for your own car: no collision, no comprehensive, no uninsured motorist coverage. A driver who hits a deer, has a car stolen, or is hit by an uninsured driver pays out of pocket. Minimum coverage makes sense for an old car worth less than the cost of a year of full coverage. For a car worth $5,000 or more, the math usually favors full coverage from one of the cheap carriers above.

Cheapest car insurance in Idaho by driver type

The cheapest carrier in Idaho changes with the driver, and the table below is the most useful one in this post. A carrier that leads for a 40 year old with a clean record may be the most expensive for a teenager or a driver with poor credit, because each insurer weighs age, record, and credit against its own Idaho claims history.

Driver type Cheapest carrier Rate Source
Good driver, full coverage GEICO $53/mo MoneyGeek, Aug 2026
Good driver, minimum coverage State Farm $18/mo MoneyGeek, Aug 2026
New driver, age 16 to 25 GEICO $124/mo MoneyGeek, Aug 2026
Poor credit Grange $139/mo MoneyGeek, July 2026
Senior, age 65 and older State Farm $63/mo MoneyGeek, July 2026
After a DUI State Farm Smallest surcharge MoneyGeek, July 2026

Teens are the most expensive drivers in the state, and GEICO is the cheapest for new drivers in Idaho at $124 a month, for a driver aged 16 to 25 added to a parent’s full coverage policy, according to MoneyGeek. If you have a driver under 25 on your policy, get a quote from Grange as well: Grange is the cheapest option for Idaho drivers from age 18 to 25, even if your main policy is with someone else, according to MoneyGeek.

Poor credit is where the ranking flips hardest. Grange charges poor credit drivers $139 a month for full coverage in Idaho, more than $100 less than the next cheapest Idaho carrier, according to MoneyGeek. If your credit is fair or poor, quote Grange first. For seniors, State Farm leads at $63 a month for drivers 65 and older, with Farm Bureau close behind at $66 a month and a low mileage discount that fits many retired Idaho drivers. After a DUI, State Farm applies the smallest surcharge of any Idaho carrier after every violation type, according to MoneyGeek, so it is the first quote to get. Insurify puts the average cost of SR-22 insurance for Idaho drivers with a past DUI at $87 a month for liability coverage and $145 a month for full coverage.

Cheapest car insurance by Idaho city

Boise is the most expensive city in Idaho for car insurance, and it is also where the cheapest carrier saves the most. GEICO is Boise’s cheapest full coverage at $54 a month, or $643 a year, which is 40 percent below the Boise city average, according to MoneyGeek. The same GEICO policy costs $41 a month in Mountain Home and Glenns Ferry. MoneyGeek ranks Boise 213th out of 260 Idaho cities for full coverage cost, and attributes it to higher traffic density and crime rates.

City Full coverage per month Cheapest carrier Cheapest full coverage
Boise $107 GEICO $54/mo
Caldwell $86 Not published Not published
Idaho Falls $83 Not published Not published
Nampa $82 Not published Not published
Pocatello $81 Not published Not published
Twin Falls $77 Not published Not published
Mountain Home Not published GEICO $41/mo

City averages in that table are MoneyGeek, July 2026, except Boise, which is Insurify, November 2026. The city spread is about $30 a month between Boise and Twin Falls for full coverage, or $360 a year. The carrier spread inside Boise is larger: GEICO at $54 a month against a Boise average of $107. Picking the right carrier in your city saves more than moving to a cheaper city.

How to actually get the cheapest rate in Idaho

Quote three carriers, and include at least one from the top of the table above. GEICO, State Farm, and American National lead for good drivers, Grange leads for poor credit and young drivers, and Travelers leads in NerdWallet’s analysis. A quote from all three takes an afternoon and can save hundreds a year.

Raise the deductible if you can cover it. Moving collision and comprehensive deductibles from $500 to $1,000 usually cuts the premium by a visible amount, and it keeps small claims off your record. Ask about telematics: several carriers offer a discount for safe driving tracked through a phone app, and the discount can run 10 to 30 percent. Ask about every discount you might qualify for: good student, multi car, bundling with home insurance, paying the annual premium in full, and a claim free history.

Keep your credit score in good shape, since Idaho carriers use it in pricing, and re-shop at every renewal. Our credit improvement guide explains what moves the score fastest. The cheapest carrier today may not be the cheapest in six months, according to MoneyGeek, because carriers reprice their Idaho books every year. A rate that was competitive last year can drift to the top of the table without any change in your driving.

Key takeaways

  • GEICO is cheapest for full coverage at $53 a month, per MoneyGeek. Travelers is cheapest at $808 a year, per NerdWallet. State Farm is cheapest at $85 a month, per ValuePenguin. The winner changes with the driver.
  • State Farm is cheapest for minimum coverage at $18 a month, or $210 a year, per MoneyGeek. American National matches the $210 a year figure in NerdWallet’s analysis.
  • By driver type: teens get the best price from GEICO at $124 a month, poor credit from Grange at $139 a month, and seniors from State Farm at $63 a month.
  • GEICO is cheapest in Boise at $54 a month, 40 percent below the Boise average, and $41 a month in Mountain Home and Glenns Ferry.
  • The company you pick matters more than the city you live in: the carrier spread is about $30 a month, against a $30 a month spread between Boise and Twin Falls.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest car insurance in Idaho in 2026?

GEICO has the cheapest full coverage in Idaho at $53 a month, according to MoneyGeek, and State Farm has the cheapest minimum coverage at $18 a month. NerdWallet names Travelers the cheapest for full coverage at $808 a year, and ValuePenguin names State Farm the cheapest at $85 a month. The winner changes with the driver, so quote at least three carriers.

How much is the cheapest full coverage car insurance in Idaho?

The cheapest full coverage in Idaho runs $53 to $55 a month for a 40 year old driver with good credit in a 2012 Camry, according to MoneyGeek, or $808 a year for a 35 year old driver in a 2023 Camry, according to NerdWallet. The state average for full coverage is $79 a month in MoneyGeek’s study and $167 a month in NerdWallet’s.

What is the cheapest car insurance in Boise, Idaho?

GEICO is the cheapest carrier in Boise at $54 a month for full coverage, or $643 a year, which is 40 percent below the Boise city average, according to MoneyGeek. Boise averages $107 a month for full coverage, the highest of any Idaho city, so the cheapest carrier saves the most there.

What is the cheapest car insurance for a teenager in Idaho?

GEICO is the cheapest carrier for new drivers in Idaho at $124 a month, according to MoneyGeek, for a driver aged 16 to 25 added to a parent’s full coverage policy. Grange is also worth quoting for drivers aged 18 to 25, since it is the cheapest option in that age band even as a standalone policy.

What is the cheapest car insurance for drivers with poor credit in Idaho?

Grange is the cheapest carrier for poor credit drivers in Idaho at $139 a month for full coverage, according to MoneyGeek, more than $100 less than the next cheapest Idaho carrier. If your credit is fair or poor, quote Grange first, and work on the credit score itself, since it moves the price more than any discount.

How can I get the cheapest car insurance in Idaho?

Quote at least three carriers, including GEICO, State Farm, and American National for good drivers, or Grange for poor credit and young drivers. Raise the deductible, ask about telematics and bundling discounts, and re-shop at every renewal, since the cheapest carrier changes as carriers reprice their Idaho books.

MoneyGeek publishes its Idaho figures in its average car insurance cost in Idaho guide and its cheapest car insurance companies ranking, updated August 2026. NerdWallet publishes its Idaho figures in its cheap car insurance in Idaho guide, updated November 2026. For the state average and the minimums, see our Idaho car insurance guide, and for the neighboring states, see our cheapest car insurance in Wyoming and cheapest car insurance in South Dakota guides.