Home Insurance

Cheapest Homeowners Insurance in New Jersey in 2026: Lowest Rates by Company and City

The cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey is Franklin Mutual at $1,003 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage, per Insurance.com. Cumberland Mutual is cheapest in the ValuePenguin and LendingTree tables at $918 and $1,056 a year, and NJM is the best-rated carrier in the state.

On this page

The cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey is Franklin Mutual at $1,003 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage, according to Insurance.com rate data for 2026. ValuePenguin names Cumberland Mutual cheapest at $918 a year for $350,000 of coverage, and LendingTree names Cumberland Mutual cheapest too, at $1,056 a year for $400,000 of coverage. MoneyGeek names Chubb cheapest at $953 a year for $250,000 of coverage. The names at the top are mostly New Jersey mutual companies, and that is the story of this market.

The state average runs $1,421 to $1,771 a year depending on the dataset and the coverage level, which puts New Jersey close to the middle of the national rankings. Home insurance here is far cheaper than car insurance in the same state, and the cheapest carriers are the ones most New Jersey homeowners have never heard of. This post compares the mutuals against the national brands, prices every coverage level, and maps the shore against the inland towns.

Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey?

Franklin Mutual has the cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey, at $1,003 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage in Insurance.com data. Cumberland Mutual is cheapest in the ValuePenguin and LendingTree tables, at $918 a year for $350,000 of coverage and $1,056 a year for $400,000. MoneyGeek names Chubb cheapest at $953 a year for $250,000 of coverage. Insure.com names National General cheapest at $1,036 a year.

Four of the five datasets name a regional mutual or a specialist carrier, not a national brand. Franklin Mutual, Cumberland Mutual, and NJM are New Jersey companies that write most of their business inside the state, and their rates beat State Farm, Allstate, and Farmers in nearly every table. The exception is MoneyGeek, where Chubb leads, and Chubb is a high-end carrier that prices aggressively for the standard profile MoneyGeek uses.

Dataset Cheapest company Rate Coverage priced
Insurance.com, 2026 Franklin Mutual $1,003/year $300,000 dwelling
ValuePenguin, 2026 Cumberland Mutual $918/year $350,000 dwelling
LendingTree, 2026 Cumberland Mutual $1,056/year $400,000 dwelling
MoneyGeek, Nov 2026 Chubb $953/year $250,000 dwelling
Insure.com, 2026 National General $1,036/year Standard profile

The lesson is to get a quote from a New Jersey mutual before accepting a national carrier’s price. Cumberland Mutual is 37 percent cheaper than the state average in the ValuePenguin table, and $118 a year cheaper than NJM, the second cheapest option there. A homeowner who only quotes the big national names never sees these numbers.

How much is homeowners insurance in New Jersey per year?

Homeowners insurance in New Jersey averages $1,449 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, according to ValuePenguin, which also ranks New Jersey the 11th cheapest state in the country. Insurance.com puts the average at $1,449 a year for $300,000 of coverage. LendingTree puts it at $1,606 a year for $400,000 of coverage. Insure.com puts it at $1,421 a year, and MoneyGeek at $1,771 a year for $250,000 of coverage.

The MoneyGeek average is the outlier on the high side, and the gap is a reminder that the coverage level matters as much as the state. MoneyGeek prices a 2000-built home with $250,000 of dwelling coverage, $125,000 of personal property, and $200,000 of liability, while ValuePenguin prices a 1,753 square foot home built 49 years ago. Same state, different home, different average.

Rates rose about 7.5 percent in New Jersey in 2025, against a 5.6 percent national increase, according to ValuePenguin rate data. That is a faster rise than the national pace, driven by storm claims along the shore and rising rebuilding costs. Even after that increase, New Jersey home insurance stays well below the national average, which is a sharp contrast with car insurance in the state, where New Jersey is one of the most expensive states in the country.

Regional mutuals against the national brands

The mutuals win in New Jersey because they know the state. Franklin Mutual, Cumberland Mutual, and NJM have written New Jersey homes for decades, and their loss data is New Jersey loss data, not a national blend. That shows up in the Insurance.com table, where Franklin Mutual is cheapest at every coverage level from $200,000 to $1 million.

Company $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $600,000 $1,000,000
Franklin Mutual $796 $1,003 $1,192 $1,551 $2,007
Allstate $755 $881 $1,057 $1,396 $1,905
Chubb $923 $1,297 $1,671 $2,477 $3,378
NJM $1,056 $1,359 $1,669 $2,311 $3,451
Farmers $1,020 $1,473 $2,039 $2,562 $3,328
Plymouth Rock $968 $1,467 $2,032 $3,447 $5,391
State Farm $1,498 $1,933 $2,369 $3,255 $4,381
USAA $1,212 $1,576 $1,906 $2,525 $3,482

Allstate is actually cheapest at the $200,000 and $300,000 levels in this table, at $755 and $881 a year, which is a useful correction to the headline that Franklin Mutual wins everywhere. Franklin Mutual takes over from $400,000 up, and its lead grows with the coverage level. At $1 million of coverage, Franklin Mutual costs $2,007 a year against $5,391 at Plymouth Rock, a gap of $3,384 a year for the same home.

The LendingTree table, which prices $400,000 of coverage, puts Cumberland Mutual first at $1,056, State Farm second at $1,155, NJM third at $1,164, and Allstate fourth at $1,205. Selective follows at $1,317, Franklin Mutual at $1,406, and Plymouth Rock last at $3,478. The order changes with the profile, and that is why three quotes from different kinds of carriers beat one quote from the biggest name.

Why NJM is the safe pick even when it is not the cheapest

NJM is rarely the cheapest carrier in New Jersey, and it is usually the best pick anyway. Its NAIC complaint rating is 0.3 in the LendingTree table, which means about 70 percent fewer complaints than the average carrier its size, and its rates sit within $100 a year of the cheapest option at most coverage levels. LendingTree scores NJM 4.5 out of 5, the highest score in its New Jersey table.

Chubb earns the top Insurance.com score in New Jersey at 4.91 out of 5, with a complaint ratio of 0.07, the lowest in the table, and an average rate of $1,297 a year for $300,000 of coverage. Chubb is a high-value specialist, so its standard-profile price is surprisingly competitive, and it is the carrier MoneyGeek names cheapest overall. A homeowner with a higher-value home should quote Chubb first.

Cheapest homeowners insurance by city in New Jersey

New Jersey home insurance rates are most expensive on the Jersey Shore, according to ValuePenguin, and the city table shows how big that gap is. Absecon averages $1,860 a year for $350,000 of coverage, with Allstate cheapest there at $1,141. Adelphia averages $1,573 a year, with Cumberland Mutual cheapest at $798. The cheapest company in a shore town can be a different carrier than the cheapest company inland, and the city average can run $300 a year above the state average. The full city table is published on ValuePenguin’s best and cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey page.

Insurance.com names ZIP code 08558, Skillman, the cheapest ZIP code in New Jersey for home insurance, at $1,096 a year. Skillman sits in central New Jersey, away from the shore and away from the densest urban areas, which is the combination that produces the lowest rates in the state. The most expensive ZIP codes cluster along the coast, where wind and flood exposure push premiums up and push some carriers out of the market entirely.

Flood insurance is the gap to watch on the shore. A standard homeowners policy does not cover flood damage, and shore homeowners need a separate flood policy, usually through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private flood carrier. The flood premium is a separate cost on top of the homeowners premium, and it can be larger than the homeowners premium itself in high-risk zones. Our guide to how much homeowners insurance costs in New Jersey covers the Atlantic City, Newark, and shore pricing in more detail.

How to get the cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey

Quote three carriers: one New Jersey mutual, one national carrier, and NJM. For most homes that means Cumberland Mutual or Franklin Mutual, Allstate or State Farm, and NJM. If the home is worth more than $500,000, add Chubb. If you are military, add USAA, which prices $1,576 a year for $300,000 of coverage in the Insurance.com table and $1,359 in the MoneyGeek table.

Then work the discounts that actually move the number in New Jersey. Bundling home and auto is the biggest, and it matters more here than in most states because New Jersey car insurance is so expensive that the bundle discount is worth more in dollars. A monitored alarm, a new roof, and a claims-free history all help, and LendingTree notes that Cumberland Mutual discounts bundling, home security systems, and newer homes in particular.

A worked example shows the saving. Take a New Jersey homeowner with $350,000 of dwelling coverage. The ValuePenguin state average is $1,449 a year. Cumberland Mutual prices the same coverage at $918 a year. That is $531 a year saved, or about 37 percent, before any bundling discount. In Adelphia, Cumberland Mutual prices the same profile at $798 a year, which is $651 below the state average. The mutual quote is the single highest-value step a New Jersey homeowner can take.

One caution: Cumberland Mutual and Franklin Mutual sell through independent agents, not direct online quotes, so getting the quote takes a phone call or an agent visit. That extra step is worth it for $500 a year. Homeowners who also need car insurance should compare both at once, since the same mutuals write auto too. Our guide to the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey names NJM cheapest for car insurance, and our New Jersey car insurance cost guide covers the new 35/70/25 minimums that took effect January 1, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey?

Franklin Mutual is cheapest at $1,003 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage, according to Insurance.com. Cumberland Mutual is cheapest in the ValuePenguin and LendingTree tables, at $918 a year for $350,000 of coverage and $1,056 a year for $400,000. MoneyGeek names Chubb cheapest at $953 a year for $250,000 of coverage.

How much does homeowners insurance cost in New Jersey on average?

The average is $1,449 a year for $350,000 of dwelling coverage, according to ValuePenguin, which ranks New Jersey the 11th cheapest state. LendingTree puts it at $1,606 a year for $400,000 of coverage, Insure.com at $1,421 a year, and MoneyGeek at $1,771 a year for $250,000 of coverage.

Is NJM good for homeowners insurance in New Jersey?

NJM is the best-rated carrier in New Jersey in the LendingTree table, with a 4.5 out of 5 score and a NAIC complaint rating of 0.3, about 70 percent fewer complaints than average. Its rates run $1,164 a year for $400,000 of coverage, within $100 of the cheapest option, so it is the safe pick when the cheapest carrier is unfamiliar.

Why is homeowners insurance more expensive on the Jersey Shore?

Shore homes face wind and storm surge exposure that inland homes do not, and some carriers restrict new policies near the coast. Absecon averages $1,860 a year for $350,000 of coverage, against a state average of $1,449. Flood damage is not covered by a standard homeowners policy, so shore homeowners need a separate flood policy on top.

How much is homeowners insurance in New Jersey for a $250,000 home?

MoneyGeek prices a $250,000 dwelling policy at $1,771 a year on average in New Jersey, with Chubb cheapest at $953 a year. At the $100,000 dwelling tier, Chubb prices $407 a year, Farmers $572, and State Farm $707. The cheapest carrier changes with the coverage level, so quote at your actual dwelling limit.

Does homeowners insurance in New Jersey cover flood damage?

No. A standard homeowners policy excludes flood damage, and shore homeowners need a separate flood policy through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private flood carrier. The flood premium is a separate cost, and in high-risk zones it can be larger than the homeowners premium itself.