Home Insurance

Cheapest Homeowners Insurance in California in 2026: Lowest Rates by Company and City

The cheapest homeowners insurance in California is Capital Insurance Group at $1,134 a year for $250,000 of dwelling coverage, per MoneyGeek, with Farmers $8 behind. Travelers is cheapest in the LendingTree and Insurance.com tables, and State Farm and Allstate are not writing new policies in the state.

On this page

The cheapest homeowners insurance in California is Capital Insurance Group at $1,134 a year for $250,000 of dwelling coverage, according to MoneyGeek data updated November 2026. Farmers is only $8 behind at $1,142 a year. LendingTree and Insurance.com both name Travelers cheapest, at $820 a year for $400,000 of coverage and $1,097 a year for $300,000. The headline number is only half the story in California, because the cheapest carrier is only useful if it is actually writing new policies, and two of the biggest names in the state are not.

California homeowners insurance averages $1,543 to $1,653 a year depending on the dataset, and the state ranks 20th most affordable of the 50 states in the Triple-I 2025 affordability index, with premiums running about 1.9 percent of median household income. The real cost driver is wildfire, and the real question is availability. This post names the cheapest carrier at every coverage tier, lists who is actually writing new policies, and explains the FAIR Plan and the wildfire hardening discounts that can cut the bill.

Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in California?

Capital Insurance Group has the cheapest homeowners insurance in California, at $1,134 a year for $250,000 of dwelling coverage in MoneyGeek data. Farmers is second at $1,142 a year, only $8 more. Travelers is cheapest in the LendingTree and Insurance.com tables, at $820 a year for $400,000 of coverage and $1,097 a year for $300,000. Insure.com also names Travelers cheapest, at $1,103 a year.

No carrier is cheapest at every tier. Farmers is cheapest at the $100,000 dwelling level at $445 a year, Capital Insurance Group is cheapest at $250,000 and at $1 million, and Progressive is cheapest at $500,000 and $750,000. A homeowner who quotes only at one coverage level can miss the cheapest carrier for their own home, so the table below prices the tiers separately.

Dataset Cheapest company Rate Coverage priced
MoneyGeek, Nov 2026 Capital Insurance Group $1,134/year $250,000 dwelling
LendingTree, 2026 Travelers $820/year $400,000 dwelling
Insurance.com, 2026 Travelers $1,097/year $300,000 dwelling
Insure.com, 2026 Travelers $1,103/year Standard profile

Capital Insurance Group is a Monterey carrier that sells only through independent agents, and it is cheapest in 28 of the 91 cities MoneyGeek prices, mostly across Orange County, the Inland Empire, and the Antelope Valley. Farmers is cheapest in 49 of the 91 cities, including Pasadena, San Francisco, San Jose, and Oxnard. Progressive is cheapest in 12 cities, including Los Angeles, Sacramento, Fresno, and Oakland.

Who is actually writing new homeowners policies in California?

State Farm and Allstate have not reopened to new California homeowners applications, according to the California Department of Insurance announcement in September 2026 that both carriers have filed to resume writing. That means two of the biggest names in American home insurance are not available to a California homeowner shopping for a new policy today, whatever their national rates look like.

Travelers is the only company among the top three in the Insurance.com ranking that is currently offering new homeowners insurance in California. That availability is part of why Travelers leads the LendingTree and Insurance.com tables: it is pricing to write business in the state while its competitors are not. A homeowner who quotes State Farm or Allstate first wastes a step, because neither can sell them a policy right now.

The carriers that are writing new policies include Travelers, Farmers, Capital Insurance Group, Progressive, Nationwide, Mercury, AAA, and Chubb. Farmers has the lowest rate in 49 of 91 cities, which makes it the most widely available cheap option in the state. Homeowners in high-risk wildfire zones may find even these carriers restricted, and that is where the California FAIR Plan comes in.

How much is homeowners insurance in California per year?

Homeowners insurance in California averages $1,574 a year for $400,000 of dwelling coverage, according to LendingTree, or $131 a month. Insurance.com puts the average at $1,653 a year for $300,000 of coverage. MoneyGeek puts it at $1,543 a year for $250,000 of coverage, and Insure.com at $1,616 a year. The four datasets agree within about $110 a year, which is unusually tight for rate studies.

LendingTree prices the coverage ladder at a $1,305 state average for $300,000 of coverage, $1,574 for $400,000, $2,221 for $550,000, and $2,903 for $750,000. Travelers prices the same ladder at $682, $820, $1,136, and $1,544, which is roughly half the state average at every level. The gap between Travelers and the state average is the largest in this week’s five posts, and it is the clearest sign that shopping around matters more in California than in most states.

California premiums run about 1.9 percent of median household income, which makes the state the 20th most affordable of 50 in the Triple-I 2025 affordability index. That ranking surprises homeowners who hear about the California insurance crisis, and the explanation is that the crisis is about availability, not the average price. The average policy is affordable. Getting one in a wildfire zone is the hard part.

Cheapest California homeowners insurance by company and coverage level

The Insurance.com table prices five coverage levels with $300,000 of liability and a $1,000 deductible. Travelers leads at every level, Allstate is second, and Farmers is the most expensive national carrier in the table at the higher levels.

Company $200,000 $300,000 $400,000 $600,000 $1,000,000
Travelers $764 $1,097 $1,414 $2,005 $2,949
Allstate $845 $1,165 $1,487 $2,147 $3,270
AAA (Auto Club) $906 $1,336 $1,765 $2,687 $4,253
CSAA (AAA) $946 $1,335 $1,687 $2,311 $2,908
Mercury $1,145 $1,555 $1,974 $2,838 $3,836
Nationwide $1,351 $1,726 $2,104 $3,081 $4,281
State Farm $1,311 $1,762 $2,265 $3,387 $4,388
Farmers $1,452 $2,048 $2,804 $4,441 $6,826
USAA $1,391 $1,690 $1,931 $2,635 $3,784

Farmers is the warning in this table. It is the second cheapest carrier in the MoneyGeek table at $1,142 a year for $250,000 of coverage, and the most expensive national carrier in the Insurance.com table at $2,048 a year for $300,000. The two datasets price different home profiles, and Farmers’ price swings more between profiles than any other carrier in the state. A homeowner who quotes Farmers should quote at their exact dwelling limit, because the price at a different limit says nothing about their own price.

MoneyGeek’s $250,000 table is tighter. Capital Insurance Group leads at $1,134 a year, Farmers at $1,142, Progressive at $1,237, Nationwide at $1,377, and Chubb at $1,843. Chubb is the most expensive in that table, and it is also the highest rated for service, with a 676 in J.D. Power’s 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study, 61 points above Farmers at 615. Chubb costs $701 more than Farmers and adds $293 for one claim, the steepest surcharge in the MoneyGeek group, so its service comes at a clear price. The full table, with rates by city and coverage level, is published on MoneyGeek’s cheapest home insurance in California page.

The FAIR Plan and the Safer from Wildfires discount

The California FAIR Plan is the insurer of last resort for homeowners who cannot get a standard policy because of wildfire risk. It covers fire damage only, not the full range of perils in a standard HO-3 policy, and it costs more for less coverage. The FAIR Plan announced an average rate increase of 30 percent, set to take effect in October 2026, according to Insurance.com, which makes it more expensive still.

Most FAIR Plan homeowners pair it with a difference-in-conditions policy that covers the perils the FAIR Plan does not, such as liability, water damage, and theft. The combined cost of the two policies is usually higher than a standard policy would be, which is why the FAIR Plan is a fallback rather than a first choice. A homeowner who can get a standard policy from Travelers, Farmers, or Capital Insurance Group should take it.

California’s Safer from Wildfires program is the one discount that can cut a real bill in a high-risk zone. The program qualifies a home for an insurance discount on each of ten hardening steps, from a Class A roof to a five-foot ember-resistant zone around the home. The steps are specific and checkable: a Class A fire-rated roof, ember-resistant vents, cleared vegetation in the first five feet, and defensible space out to 100 feet. A homeowner who completes the steps should tell their carrier, because the discount is not always applied automatically. Our guide to wildfire coverage in home insurance covers what California and western homeowners should know about fire coverage.

How to get the cheapest homeowners insurance in California

Quote Travelers, Farmers, and Capital Insurance Group first, then add Progressive if the home is worth $500,000 or more. Skip State Farm and Allstate until they reopen to new applications, and check the Department of Insurance announcement before assuming they are back. If you are military, add USAA, which prices $1,338 a year for $400,000 of coverage in the LendingTree table.

Then work the discounts that actually move the number in California. Bundling home and auto is the biggest, and the Safer from Wildfires hardening steps are the most California-specific saving available. A new roof, a monitored alarm, and a claims-free history all help, and raising the deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 cuts the premium further, as long as you can pay $2,500 out of pocket after a loss.

A worked example shows the saving. Take a California homeowner with $400,000 of dwelling coverage. The LendingTree state average is $1,574 a year. Travelers prices the same coverage at $820 a year, a saving of $754 a year, or about 48 percent. At $300,000 of coverage, the Insurance.com state average is $1,653 a year and Travelers prices $1,097, a saving of $556 a year. Either way, the Travelers quote is worth roughly $500 to $750 a year against the state average, before any bundling or hardening discount.

One more check before you buy: confirm the policy covers wildfire at the standard deductible, not a separate wildfire deductible, and confirm the dwelling limit matches rebuilding cost in your area. California rebuilding costs run high, and underinsuring the dwelling is the most expensive mistake a California homeowner can make. Homeowners who also drive in the state should compare auto at the same time. Our guide to the cheapest car insurance in California names Travelers cheapest there too, and our California homeowners cost guide covers rates by region and carrier. California drivers should also check our guide to California minimum car insurance requirements for the state minimums.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest homeowners insurance in California?

Capital Insurance Group is cheapest at $1,134 a year for $250,000 of dwelling coverage, according to MoneyGeek, with Farmers only $8 behind at $1,142. Travelers is cheapest in the LendingTree and Insurance.com tables, at $820 a year for $400,000 of coverage and $1,097 a year for $300,000. No carrier is cheapest at every coverage tier.

How much does homeowners insurance cost in California on average?

The average is $1,574 a year for $400,000 of dwelling coverage, according to LendingTree. Insurance.com puts it at $1,653 a year for $300,000 of coverage, MoneyGeek at $1,543 for $250,000, and Insure.com at $1,616. California ranks 20th most affordable of the 50 states in the Triple-I 2025 affordability index.

Is State Farm writing new homeowners policies in California?

No. State Farm and Allstate have not reopened to new California homeowners applications, according to the California Department of Insurance announcement in September 2026 that both carriers have filed to resume writing. Travelers is the only company among the top three in the Insurance.com ranking that is currently offering new homeowners insurance in California.

What is the California FAIR Plan?

The California FAIR Plan is the insurer of last resort for homeowners who cannot get a standard policy because of wildfire risk. It covers fire damage only, not the full range of perils in a standard HO-3 policy, and it costs more for less coverage. The FAIR Plan announced an average rate increase of 30 percent, set to take effect in October 2026.

How can I lower my homeowners insurance in California?

California’s Safer from Wildfires program qualifies a home for an insurance discount on each of ten hardening steps, from a Class A roof to a five-foot ember-resistant zone. Bundling home and auto, raising the deductible to $2,500, and quoting Travelers, Farmers, and Capital Insurance Group together can save roughly $500 to $750 a year against the state average.

Does homeowners insurance in California cover wildfire damage?

A standard HO-3 policy covers fire damage, including wildfire, unless the policy specifically excludes it. Some carriers in high-risk zones apply a separate wildfire deductible or restrict coverage, so read the fire wording before buying. Earthquake damage is not covered by a standard policy and needs a separate endorsement.