On this page
Why new riders pay so much more
Age is the single biggest price driver in motorcycle insurance. ValuePenguin’s 2026 data puts the average full coverage policy for a 16-year-old at $1,232 a year, or about $103 a month. By age 20, the average drops to roughly $62 a month. A 40-year-old with a clean record pays around $33 a month for the same coverage level. The pattern is consistent: insurers price lack of riding history as crash risk, and the numbers show they are not wrong to.
That first policy is still worth buying correctly. New riders who cheap out on liability limits to hit a monthly number can end up personally exposed after their first serious crash, which is exactly when inexperience makes a crash most likely.
Get your endorsement before you shop
Most carriers require a valid motorcycle endorsement to write a policy, and riding without one can void coverage. The Motorcycle Safety Foundation Basic RiderCourse does double duty here: it satisfies the licensing requirement in most states, and it earns a premium discount. Carrier data cited by Riders Share shows most major insurers recognize MSF course completion with a 10 to 15 percent discount on the premium.
The course usually runs a weekend and costs a few hundred dollars. Between the license waiver and the recurring discount, it pays for itself within the first year for most new riders.
Seven ways new riders keep the first policy affordable
Start with a smaller, used bike. Insurance prices track engine size and bike value closely, and a mid-size cruiser or standard costs far less to insure than a supersport. Sport bikes run 2.5 to 3.5 times the price of a comparable cruiser to insure. Your first bike does not need to be your dream bike.
Choose liability-only if the bike is cheap and paid off. If you bought a used starter bike for a few thousand dollars in cash, paying $1,000 a year for full coverage makes little sense. Liability-only keeps you legal while the crash risk is mostly your own repair bill.
Stay on a parent’s policy if you can. A teen on a parent’s multi-policy account typically costs far less than the same teen with a standalone policy, because multi-vehicle and bundling discounts apply. A teen’s own policy versus staying on a parent’s policy is one of the largest cost decisions a young rider’s family makes.
Raise the deductible deliberately. A $1,000 deductible instead of $250 can cut the physical damage portion of the premium substantially. Only do this if you actually have the thousand dollars set aside.
Store the bike securely from day one. A locked garage beats a driveway, and a disc lock or alarm earns small additional reductions that add up for a young rider’s budget.
Keep the car record clean. Violations on a car license follow into motorcycle pricing, and for a new rider with no history, one ticket carries outsized weight. The factors that affect car insurance rates apply almost one-to-one to motorcycle quotes.
Shop the rider-focused carriers. Dairyland averages $22 a month for full coverage nationally, and Progressive is frequently cheapest for young riders by state. Get at least three quotes before buying, since carrier pricing for new riders varies more than for experienced ones.
What new riders usually get wrong
The common mistake is buying the bike first and shopping insurance second. A supersport that fits the budget as a purchase can be unaffordable once the insurance quote arrives. Get the quote before you sign anything.
The second mistake is skipping uninsured motorist coverage to save money. New riders are the most likely to need it and the least likely to buy it. A hit-and-run driver is a personal financial disaster without it.
Finally, compare quotes on identical coverage levels rather than chasing the lowest monthly number. A cheaper quote with half the liability limit is not a better deal.
