On this page
If you ask ten drivers what they pay for full coverage car insurance, you will hear ten different numbers. That is not because insurers are guessing. Your state is one of the biggest factors in your premium, and the gap between the cheapest and priciest states is enormous. A driver in Idaho can pay less than half of what a driver in Florida pays for the same coverage.
This guide explains what full coverage costs by state in 2026, why the numbers swing so much, and what you can actually do about it. To see what full coverage includes before we talk price, read our guide on what full coverage car insurance is and whether you need it.
What full coverage actually includes
Full coverage is not a policy type you buy off the shelf. It is a bundle: liability coverage, collision coverage, and comprehensive coverage together. Liability pays for damage you cause to other people and their property. Collision pays to repair your car after an accident, regardless of fault. Comprehensive covers everything else, like theft, hail, falling branches, and hitting a deer.
Because collision and comprehensive repair your own car, they are the parts most tied to where you live. Hail in Texas, theft in California, hurricanes in Florida, and deer in Pennsylvania all show up in comprehensive rates. That is why full coverage varies by state far more than liability-only policies do.
Why full coverage costs vary so much by state
Every state sets its own insurance rules, and insurers set prices state by state based on what they expect to pay in claims. A few things separate cheap states from expensive ones:
No-fault and litigation rules. States like Florida and Michigan have insurance systems that push more costs into the auto policy. Michigan reformed its no-fault system in recent years, but it still sits near the top of national cost rankings. New York’s high litigation and fraud rates do the same thing there.
Weather and natural disasters. Hurricanes in the Southeast, hail across the central states, and wildfires in California all produce waves of comprehensive claims. Insurers pass those losses into premiums, sometimes for the whole state.
Repair costs. Labor rates, parts availability, and how new the average car on the road is all differ by state. Modern cars with cameras and sensors cost more to repair everywhere, but the effect compounds in states where labor is already expensive.
Uninsured drivers. States with high rates of uninsured motorists force insurers to pay more uninsured motorist claims. Those costs land in everyone else’s premiums.
Regulation. Some states let insurers raise rates quickly when costs jump. Others make them justify every increase to a regulator, which slows both hikes and corrections.
Where full coverage is cheapest and priciest in 2026
National industry reports put the projected 2026 average full coverage premium around $2,158 a year, roughly flat after a decline in 2025. But averages hide the real story. Idaho is consistently reported among the cheapest states for full coverage. On the other end, Florida, Michigan, and Nevada regularly show up as the priciest, with full coverage running two to three times the cheapest states.
The pattern is stable year after year: rural states with light traffic and mild weather pay the least, while states with dense traffic, expensive repairs, heavy litigation, or frequent severe weather pay the most. Your own rate will still depend on your car, your record, and your credit in most states, but your state sets the starting point.
What your state’s average does not tell you
State averages are useful for comparing states, not for judging your own quote. Two drivers in the same state can pay wildly different amounts. A clean record in an expensive state can still beat a DUI and an at-fault accident in a cheap state. Insurers also price by ZIP code, not just state, so the difference between a quiet suburb and a busy downtown in the same state can be bigger than the difference between two states.
That is why shopping matters more than any average. Quotes for identical coverage can differ by hundreds of dollars a year between insurers in the same ZIP code. Our guide on how to compare insurance quotes the right way shows how to make sure you are comparing like with like.
How to pay less for full coverage in your state
You cannot change your state’s rules, but you can change what you pay inside them. Raise your deductible if you can afford to pay more out of pocket after a claim. A higher collision deductible is one of the fastest ways to cut a full coverage bill. Drop collision and comprehensive on an older car that is worth less than a few thousand dollars, if you can replace it without insurance money.
Ask about every discount you qualify for: bundling, good driver, low mileage, paperless billing, and telematics programs that track your driving. And re-shop your policy at least once a year. Loyalty is rarely rewarded in auto insurance. If your state only requires minimum liability, make sure you actually need full coverage before you pay for it, which our minimum car insurance by state guide can help you weigh.
