On this page
Travelers has the cheapest full coverage car insurance in Florida in 2026 on two datasets, at $2,448 a year per CarInsurance.com and $204 a month per CheapCarInsurance.net and Quadrant Information Services, using Florida rates in effect September 30, 2026. Other studies name GEICO or State Farm cheapest instead, because each one prices a different driver. Florida is one of the most expensive states for car insurance, with a statewide full coverage average of $203 to $332 a month depending on the study, so the carrier you choose can save you more than $100 a month. This guide compares six datasets, breaks down the cheapest carrier by city, and explains the law change scheduled for July 2026.
There is no single cheapest carrier in Florida, and any guide that names one without naming the study behind it is hiding the ball. CarInsurance.com and CheapCarInsurance.net both price a 40 year old benchmark driver and both name Travelers. NerdWallet prices a 2023 Toyota Camry and names GEICO. Insurify prices live quotes and names State Farm. ValuePenguin prices a 30 year old man with good credit and names GEICO. MoneyGeek prices a 40 year old man with good credit driving a 2012 Camry and names Travelers by a wide margin. Each answer is right for the driver it priced.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Florida?
Travelers averages $2,448 a year for full coverage, or about $204 a month, in the CarInsurance.com and CheapCarInsurance.net data, the cheapest of the major insurers both sources compared. GEICO averages $175 a month for full coverage in the NerdWallet November 2026 analysis, the cheapest in that study. State Farm averages $125 a month for full coverage in the Insurify November 2026 data, the cheapest there. ValuePenguin puts GEICO first at $213 a month, with State Farm second at $215 and Travelers third at $239. MoneyGeek puts Travelers first at $95 a month, with State Farm second at $114.
| Source and driver priced | Cheapest full coverage | State average full coverage |
|---|---|---|
| CarInsurance.com, Aug 2026 | Travelers $2,448 a year | $326 a month ($3,916 a year) |
| CheapCarInsurance.net / Quadrant, Sep 30 2026, benchmark driver | Travelers $204 a month, GEICO $254 | $332 a month |
| Experian Sep 2026, marketplace quotes | Travelers $177 a month, Mercury $193, Lemonade $207 | $228 a month |
| NerdWallet Nov 2026, 2023 Camry LE, 12,000 miles a year | GEICO $175 a month, UAIC $191, Travelers $194 | Not published separately |
| Insurify Nov 1 2026, live quotes | State Farm $125 a month, Progressive $142 | $235 a month |
| ValuePenguin, 30 year old man, good credit, 2018 Civic | GEICO $213 a month, State Farm $215, Travelers $239 | $311 a month |
| MoneyGeek, 40 year old man, clean record, good credit, 2012 Camry | Travelers $95 a month, State Farm $114, GEICO $168 | $203 a month |
Travelers is cheapest in three of the seven datasets, GEICO in two, and State Farm in one, with Experian also naming Travelers. That makes Travelers the most frequent winner, but the range of winning prices, $95 a month to $213 a month, shows how much the driver profile moves the answer. MoneyGeek prices a 40 year old with a $1,000 deductible, ValuePenguin a 30 year old with a $500 deductible, and NerdWallet a newer car with 12,000 miles a year. Compare the carriers that win most often, Travelers, GEICO, and State Farm, at your own profile, and the winner for you will emerge from your quotes rather than from a table.
What is the cheapest car insurance in Florida by city?
City matters as much as carrier in Florida. Full coverage averages $186 a month in Tallahassee and $315 a month in Tampa and Miami, per MoneyGeek, a $129 monthly difference that adds up to $1,548 a year for the same driver and the same coverage. ValuePenguin puts the Jacksonville average at $300 a month, with GEICO cheapest there at $188 a month. The cheapest carrier also changes by city. State Farm has the lowest rates in 59 percent of Florida cities and towns in the ValuePenguin data, including St. Petersburg, Port St. Lucie, Tallahassee, and Fort Lauderdale, while GEICO has the cheapest rates in 33 percent of cities, including Jacksonville, Miami, Tampa, and Orlando.
| City | Average full coverage per month | Cheapest carrier and rate | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tallahassee | $186 | State Farm, cheapest in city | MoneyGeek / ValuePenguin |
| Jacksonville | $300 | GEICO $188 | ValuePenguin |
| Tampa | $315 | GEICO, cheapest in city | MoneyGeek / ValuePenguin |
| Miami | $315 | GEICO, cheapest in city | MoneyGeek / ValuePenguin |
| Orlando | Not published separately | GEICO, cheapest in city | ValuePenguin |
| St. Petersburg | Not published separately | State Farm, cheapest in city | ValuePenguin |
| Florida statewide | $203 to $332 | Travelers, GEICO, or State Farm depending on study | Six datasets |
The city table carries a practical lesson. A driver in Tallahassee should start with State Farm, because it is cheapest there and the city average is already low. A driver in Miami should start with GEICO, because it is cheapest there even though the city average is high. A driver who moves from Tallahassee to Miami should expect the premium to rise by about $129 a month on the same coverage, before changing carriers. Get quotes from the carrier that wins your city first, then add the statewide winners, Travelers and GEICO, for comparison.
What is the cheapest minimum coverage in Florida?
GEICO has the cheapest minimum coverage in Florida at $30 a month, or $365 a year, per NerdWallet November 2026. CheapCarInsurance.net puts GEICO cheapest for liability only at $82 a month for 15/30/10 limits, with Travelers next at $97 a month. Experian puts Root cheapest for minimum coverage at $103 a month, or $1,237 a year. ValuePenguin puts GEICO cheapest for minimum coverage at $37 a month. MoneyGeek puts Travelers cheapest for minimum coverage at $44 a month, with State Farm second at $52. The spread across studies is $30 to $103 a month, again because the driver profiles differ.
Florida minimum coverage today is $10,000 in personal injury protection and $10,000 in property damage liability, known as 10/10. That is the lowest minimum in the country for bodily injury, because Florida does not currently require bodily injury liability at all. Minimum coverage meets the law, but it leaves you exposed. Ten thousand dollars in property damage does not cover a new car, and ten thousand in PIP does not cover a serious injury. Most drivers who can afford it buy bodily injury liability limits of at least 100/300, plus comprehensive and collision if the car is financed.
What is changing in Florida car insurance law in 2026?
Florida is scheduled to end its no fault PIP system on July 1, 2026, replacing it with mandatory bodily injury liability coverage, per InsureMojo and its summary of the 2026 law change. Under the current system, every driver must carry $10,000 in PIP and $10,000 in property damage liability. Under the new system, drivers would carry bodily injury liability instead of PIP, which changes what the policy pays and who it pays. The change has been proposed before and delayed before, so treat July 1, 2026 as the scheduled date rather than a certainty, and confirm the requirement with the Florida Department of Financial Services or your insurer at renewal.
The reason the change matters for price is that PIP fraud has been a major driver of Florida premiums for years. No fault PIP pays medical bills regardless of who caused the crash, and that structure attracted staged accidents and inflated billing, concentrated in South Florida. Moving to a fault based bodily injury system is intended to reduce that fraud, though whether it lowers premiums in practice will depend on how the new system is implemented and how carriers reprice. If you renew after July 1, 2026, expect your quote to look different, and compare it against a fresh set of carriers rather than assuming your current one is still cheapest.
Why is car insurance so expensive in Florida?
Hurricanes are the first driver. A single storm damages thousands of cars at once, and comprehensive claims spike after every major hurricane. Litigation is the second. Florida has a long history of high auto insurance lawsuit rates, and legal costs get priced into every policy. Fraud is the third, with PIP fraud and staged accidents concentrated in Miami, Tampa, and Orlando. Population growth is the fourth, with more drivers, more miles, and more crashes on roads that were not built for the current volume. Together they explain why Florida full coverage averages $203 to $332 a month while the national average is about $187 a month.
Allstate is the most expensive major insurer in the CarInsurance.com data at $5,064 a year for full coverage, against Travelers at $2,448. That $2,616 annual gap between the cheapest and the most expensive major carrier is the largest single reason to shop. A driver who renews with Allstate without comparing quotes can pay more than double the Travelers rate for the same coverage.
A worked example: a Tampa driver shops three carriers
Take a 30 year old driver in Tampa with a clean record and good credit, driving a 2018 Honda Civic, buying full coverage. ValuePenguin puts GEICO at $213 a month for that profile statewide, with State Farm at $215 and Travelers at $239. Tampa averages $315 a month for full coverage on the MoneyGeek profile, so the Tampa driver should expect to pay above the statewide GEICO figure. GEICO is cheapest in Tampa in the ValuePenguin city data, which makes it the first quote to get.
Now compare the same driver on the NerdWallet profile, a 2023 Toyota Camry with 12,000 miles a year. NerdWallet puts GEICO at $175 a month for full coverage statewide, with UAIC at $191 and Travelers at $194. The two profiles give GEICO figures of $213 and $175 a month, a $38 monthly gap for what looks like the same driver. The difference is the car, the age, and the limits, which is why the worked example matters. The Tampa driver should get quotes from GEICO, State Farm, and Travelers at identical limits and deductibles, then compare the three actual quotes rather than the three study figures. On the MoneyGeek profile, the same exercise gives Travelers at $95 a month against GEICO at $168, a $73 monthly gap in the other direction, which shows that the winner flips when the profile changes.
How to find the cheapest car insurance in Florida
Start with Travelers, GEICO, and State Farm, because one of the three wins nearly every 2026 study. Add Progressive, which Insurify puts second cheapest at $142 a month, and Mercury, which Experian puts second cheapest at $193 a month. Get all quotes at the same limits and deductibles, and ask each carrier about bundling with homeowners insurance, telematics, low mileage, and good driver discounts. Florida homeowners who bundle can save on both policies, and Florida homeowners insurance by county shows what the home side costs.
Recheck every year, and recheck again after July 1, 2026, when the PIP system is scheduled to end. A law change that reshuffles coverage will reshuffle carrier pricing, and the carrier that was cheapest under PIP may not be cheapest under bodily injury liability. If you are comparing states, car insurance in Texas averages $190 to $259 a month for full coverage, below Florida, and how much car insurance costs per year puts Florida in the national picture. For monthly budgeting, see how much car insurance costs per month for one person.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest car insurance in Florida in 2026?
Travelers, at $2,448 a year for full coverage per CarInsurance.com, or $204 a month per CheapCarInsurance.net and Quadrant. GEICO is cheapest in the NerdWallet study at $175 a month, and State Farm is cheapest in the Insurify data at $125 a month. The winner depends on the driver profile, so compare quotes from all three.
How much is full coverage car insurance in Florida?
The statewide average runs $203 to $332 a month depending on the study. CarInsurance.com puts it at $326 a month, CheapCarInsurance.net at $332, Experian at $228, Insurify at $235, ValuePenguin at $311, and MoneyGeek at $203. Tampa and Miami average about $315 a month, while Tallahassee averages $186.
What is the cheapest minimum car insurance in Florida?
GEICO, at $30 a month per NerdWallet, or $37 a month per ValuePenguin. CheapCarInsurance.net puts GEICO cheapest for liability only at $82 a month, and Experian puts Root cheapest for minimum coverage at $103 a month.
Is Florida getting rid of no fault car insurance?
Florida is scheduled to end its no fault PIP system on July 1, 2026, replacing it with mandatory bodily injury liability coverage. The change has been proposed and delayed before, so confirm the requirement with the Florida Department of Financial Services or your insurer at renewal.
What is the minimum car insurance required in Florida?
Ten thousand dollars in personal injury protection and $10,000 in property damage liability, through June 30, 2026. Florida does not currently require bodily injury liability, which makes its minimum the lowest in the country for bodily injury.
Why is car insurance so expensive in Florida?
Hurricanes, litigation, PIP fraud concentrated in South Florida, and rapid population growth all push claims costs up. The national average for full coverage is about $187 a month, while Florida runs $203 to $332 a month depending on the study.
ValuePenguin publishes the Florida rates used above on its cheapest car insurance in Florida page, based on 442,470 quotes from six leading Florida insurers for a 30 year old man with good credit driving a 2018 Honda Civic.
