On this page
Your roof is the single biggest factor insurers can see from the curb, and its material changes your premium in two ways: how likely it is to be damaged, and how much it costs to replace. Asphalt shingles and metal roofing sit at opposite ends of that math.
Why insurers care about roof material
Roof claims are among the most expensive and most frequent homeowners claims. Hail, wind, and fallen branches all hit the roof first. A material that resists hail and lasts 40 to 50 years generates fewer and smaller claims than one that needs replacing every 15 to 25 years. Insurers price that difference into your premium.
Metal roofs: the insurance favorite
Standing-seam metal roofs resist hail, shed snow, and handle high winds well. Many insurers offer discounts or more favorable terms for metal roofs, and some extend better roof-coverage terms because the expected claim frequency is lower. The tradeoff is upfront cost: metal typically costs two to three times what asphalt shingles cost to install. The insurance savings alone rarely pay for the roof, but combined with longevity and energy savings, the total math can work.
Asphalt shingles: cheap to install, pricier to insure over time
Architectural asphalt shingles are the most common residential roofing in the US because they are affordable and easy to install. Insurers cover them readily when new. The catch is aging: as shingles approach 15 to 20 years, many insurers switch roof coverage from replacement cost to actual cash value, raise premiums, or in hail-prone states decline to renew. An older shingle roof is the most common reason a homeowner gets a non-renewal letter.
What actually moves your rate
Material is one input. Roof age matters more for shingles than for metal. Impact-resistant shingles (Class 4 rated) can earn discounts close to what metal earns, at a lower installed cost, and several states mandate the discount. Roof shape matters too: hip roofs handle wind better than gable roofs and often earn credits in hurricane states.
For the claims side of roof coverage, see how insurers handle roof replacement claims, including the age, wear, and storm rules that decide whether you get paid.
What to do before you re-roof
Call your insurer before you sign a roofing contract, not after. Ask how each material and each impact rating changes your premium and your roof coverage terms. Get the answer in writing. Then compare the installed cost against the expected insurance savings over the roof’s life, not just year one.
If you are buying a home, ask the seller for the roof’s age and material, and get an insurance quote with those specifics. A 22-year-old shingle roof can add hundreds a year to your premium or force you into actual cash value coverage from day one. The roof you cannot see in the listing photos is the one that sets your rate.
