On this page
Car insurance in New Jersey costs $2,923 a year for full coverage, or about $244 a month, in Insurify’s mid-2026 data. That is 31 percent above the national average of $2,237 a year, and New Jersey ranks ninth most expensive of the 50 states. Other studies put the number higher, up to $3,597 a year with Experian, because they price different drivers and different coverage limits. The honest range for a typical New Jersey driver with a clean record is roughly $2,900 to $3,200 a year for full coverage, and the company matters more than the state average: the cheapest full coverage in the state runs about $1,455 to $2,373 a year depending on the study, which is a gap of more than $900 a year for the same driver.
Two things changed for New Jersey drivers in 2026, and both push the price up. The state raised its minimum liability limits on January 1, 2026, from 25/50/25 to 35/70/25, which is higher than most states. And New Jersey drivers absorbed the largest rate increase in the nation in 2025, at 20 percent, according to Insurify. The figures below come from Insurify, Experian, MoneyGeek, Insure.com, and Luva, and where they disagree, the disagreement is shown rather than smoothed over.
How much does car insurance cost in New Jersey?
Insurify puts full coverage in New Jersey at $2,923 a year, or $244 a month, based on real quotes for drivers aged 20 to 70 with clean records and average or better credit. Experian puts it at $3,597 a year, or $300 a month, based on policies sold through its marketplace in the 12 months to October 2026. MoneyGeek puts it lowest, at $2,160 a year, or $180 a month, pricing 100/300/100 limits with a $1,000 deductible. Insure.com puts it at $3,122 a year, or $260 a month, and Luva puts it at $3,158 a year, or $263 a month, from Quadrant Information Services rate data.
The spread looks wide until the drivers are compared. Insurify reports a median across real quotes. MoneyGeek prices a $1,000 deductible where the others price $500. Experian averages policies actually sold, which skews toward drivers who buy more coverage. Insurify projects New Jersey full coverage will rise another 1.4 percent by the end of 2026, to roughly $3,024 a year. Read together, the studies point to the same conclusion: a typical New Jersey driver pays somewhere around $2,900 to $3,200 a year for full coverage, and the exact number depends heavily on the city, the company, and the driver’s record.
| Study | Full coverage, per year | Full coverage, per month | Minimum coverage, per year | Updated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Insurify, mid-2026 | $2,923 | $244 | $1,052 | August 16, 2026 |
| Experian, October 2026 | $3,597 | $300 | Not listed | October 2026 |
| MoneyGeek, 2026 | $2,160 | $180 | $1,285 | 2026 |
| Insure.com, 2026 | $3,122 | $260 | $1,395 | 2026 |
| Luva, 2026 | $3,158 | $263 | $1,655 | 2026 |
Minimum coverage is the cheapest legal option, and it pays nothing toward the driver’s own car. Insurify prices New Jersey liability only at roughly $1,052 a year, MoneyGeek at $1,285, Insure.com at $1,395, and Luva at $1,655. The gap between minimum and full coverage runs roughly $900 to $1,800 a year depending on the study, which is the price of collision and comprehensive coverage for the driver’s own vehicle. A driver with a financed or leased car does not get to choose: the lender requires full coverage.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey?
Three studies name three different winners, and the disagreement is the most useful fact in this post. Insure.com names NJM cheapest at $2,373 a year for full coverage with 100/300/100 limits and $500 deductibles. Experian names Travelers cheapest at $1,992 a year. Insurify names NJM cheapest at $147 a month for full coverage and $119 a month for liability only, with Plymouth Rock next at $203 a month for full coverage. Luva names GEICO cheapest at $174 a month for full coverage, with NJM a dollar behind at $176. MoneyGeek names Plymouth Rock cheapest at $121 a month for full coverage.
The reason is the same as with the averages: different drivers, different limits, and different rate dates. NJM appears at or near the top in three of the five studies, which makes it the first quote to get. Travelers and GEICO each lead one study, and Plymouth Rock leads one. The practical shortlist is NJM, GEICO, Travelers, and Plymouth Rock, and the cheapest of the four for a specific driver can only be found by quoting all four. A driver who only quotes one of them can overpay by $500 a year or more without knowing it.
| Company | Insure.com, full coverage | Experian, full coverage | Insurify, full coverage | MoneyGeek, full coverage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NJM | $2,373 a year | Not listed | $147 a month | Not listed |
| Travelers | Not listed | $1,992 a year | Not listed | Not listed |
| GEICO | Not listed | $3,704 a year | Not listed | Not listed |
| Plymouth Rock | Not listed | $2,847 a year | $203 a month | $121 a month |
| AAA Insurance | Not listed | $2,700 a year | Not listed | Not listed |
| Selective Insurance | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed | $126 a month |
One warning sits inside the table. Experian prices GEICO at $3,704 a year for full coverage, the most expensive of its five carriers, while Luva prices GEICO cheapest at $174 a month. The two studies price different drivers at different dates, and the gap shows how much a single rating factor can move one company’s price. No single study settles who is cheapest for a specific driver. The only number that matters is the quote for that driver’s address, car, and record.
What changed on January 1, 2026: the new 35/70/25 minimums
New Jersey raised its minimum liability limits on January 1, 2026, for policies issued or renewed on or after that date. The new minimum is $35,000 per person and $70,000 per accident for bodily injury, and $25,000 per accident for property damage, written as 35/70/25. The old minimum was 25/50/25. The state also requires $15,000 in personal injury protection. The increase was the second phase of a planned coverage hike, and it means every New Jersey driver now carries more liability coverage than drivers in most other states.
New Jersey is a choice no-fault state, which is a second fact that shapes the price. Personal injury protection is mandatory, so the driver’s own insurer pays medical costs after a crash regardless of who caused it, and claims get paid more often than in a traditional at-fault state. Drivers choose between a limited right to sue and an unlimited right to sue when they buy the policy. The limited option costs less and restricts lawsuits to serious injuries. The unlimited option costs more and preserves the full right to sue. The choice is made at purchase, and many drivers never notice which one they picked until after a crash.
The higher minimums are good news for anyone hit by a New Jersey driver, and they are a cost for every New Jersey driver. A $35,000 bodily injury limit is still less than the cost of one serious hospital stay, so the minimum remains a floor rather than a recommendation. The 100/300/100 limits used in most of the studies above cost more per month, but they are the limits most New Jersey agents recommend for a driver with a house or savings to protect. Our guide to car insurance cost in Michigan, the other big no-fault state, shows how the same system prices in a different market, and our vanishing deductible guide explains one way to cut the out-of-pocket cost after a claim.
What does car insurance cost in Newark and Trenton?
Every city in New Jersey’s ten most populous costs above the state average, and Newark costs the most. MoneyGeek prices full coverage in Newark at $248 a month, against $191 a month in Trenton, a $57 a month gap that adds up to $684 a year. The state average in the same data is $180 a month, so even Trenton, the cheapest of the ten, sits above it. The pattern is consistent across every study: dense, urban, and close to New York costs the most, and the price falls as the driver moves south and west.
The city gap is the second-largest lever in New Jersey car insurance after the company. A driver moving from Newark to Trenton saves $684 a year in the MoneyGeek data without changing anything else. A driver moving the other way should expect the premium to rise by roughly a third. The studies disagree on the level by $60 to $80 a month for the same city, which is a reminder that none of them is a quote, but they agree on the order, and the order is what matters for shopping.
| City | MoneyGeek, full coverage | MoneyGeek, minimum coverage |
|---|---|---|
| Newark | $248 a month | Not listed |
| Trenton | $191 a month | Not listed |
| State average | $180 a month | $107 a month |
Credit moves a New Jersey car premium almost as much as the city. MoneyGeek finds drivers with good credit paying $172 a month for full coverage, against $286 a month for drivers with poor credit, a $114 a month difference that adds up to $1,368 more per year. The credit penalty is larger than the gap between Newark and Trenton, and it applies to the whole state rather than to one town. A driver whose credit has improved since the last renewal should ask for a re-rate, and a driver whose credit has slipped should get quotes from more companies rather than fewer.
Why New Jersey car insurance jumped 20 percent in 2025
New Jersey drivers absorbed the largest rate increase in the nation in 2025, at 20 percent, according to Insurify’s rate-tracking data. The increase followed years of rising repair costs, higher medical costs, and more expensive claims, and it landed on a state that was already ninth most expensive in the country. Insurify projects a further 1.4 percent rise by the end of 2026, to roughly $3,024 a year for full coverage, which is a slower pace than 2025 but still an increase on an already high base.
The increase is the reason the cheapest company matters more in New Jersey than in most states. When the state average rises 20 percent in a year, the gap between companies widens with it, and a driver who renews without shopping absorbs the full increase. The four names on the shortlist, NJM, GEICO, Travelers, and Plymouth Rock, each lead a different study, which means the cheapest company for a specific driver is genuinely uncertain until quoted. Getting all four quotes takes an afternoon, and the saving can run to $500 a year or more. For comparison, our guide to car insurance in Louisiana, the most expensive state in the country, shows what the same factors cost where the base rate is higher still, and our car insurance in New Hampshire guide shows a cheaper New England market. Drivers weighing the vehicle itself can read our car insurance cost by vehicle type guide.
Frequently asked questions
How much is car insurance in New Jersey?
Full coverage car insurance in New Jersey costs $2,923 a year, or about $244 a month, in Insurify’s mid-2026 data. Other studies range from $2,160 a year with MoneyGeek to $3,597 a year with Experian, because they price different drivers and deductibles. A realistic range for a typical New Jersey driver with a clean record is roughly $2,900 to $3,200 a year for full coverage.
Which company has the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey?
Three studies name three different winners: Insure.com names NJM cheapest at $2,373 a year, Experian names Travelers cheapest at $1,992 a year, and MoneyGeek names Plymouth Rock cheapest at $121 a month. NJM appears at or near the top in three of the five studies, which makes it the first quote to get, followed by GEICO, Travelers, and Plymouth Rock.
What is the minimum car insurance in New Jersey in 2026?
New Jersey requires $35,000 per person and $70,000 per accident for bodily injury, $25,000 per accident for property damage, and $15,000 in personal injury protection, written as 35/70/25. The limits rose from 25/50/25 on January 1, 2026. Minimum coverage costs $1,052 to $1,655 a year depending on the study, and it pays nothing toward the driver’s own car.
Why is car insurance so expensive in New Jersey?
New Jersey is the ninth most expensive state for full coverage, at $2,923 a year against a national average of $2,237. The state is a choice no-fault state, so mandatory personal injury protection means claims get paid more often. Dense cities, high repair and medical costs, and the largest rate increase in the nation in 2025, at 20 percent, all push the price up.
How much does car insurance cost in Newark vs Trenton?
Full coverage in Newark costs $248 a month in the MoneyGeek data, against $191 a month in Trenton, a $57 a month gap that adds up to $684 a year. Every city in New Jersey’s ten most populous costs above the state average of $180 a month, and Newark costs the most.
The short version: expect around $2,923 a year for full coverage in New Jersey, per Insurify, with Newark running $248 a month and Trenton $191 in the MoneyGeek data. No single study settles who is cheapest, with NJM, Travelers, and Plymouth Rock each leading a different study, so the practical shortlist is all four names plus GEICO. The two numbers that matter most after the premium are the new 35/70/25 minimums, which took effect January 1, 2026, and the driver’s own rating factors, where poor credit adds $1,368 a year in the MoneyGeek data. Insure.com’s New Jersey car insurance cost page and the New Jersey cost summary citing Insurify’s mid-2026 data are the sources for the figures above.