On this page
Homeowners insurance in New Jersey costs $1,236 a year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage, according to Insurify data updated November 17, 2026. That is less than half the national average of $2,772 a year for the same coverage, and it puts New Jersey among the five cheapest states in the country for home insurance. The surprise is real, and it has a catch. The statewide average hides a coastal split: Atlantic City runs $3,715 a year for a larger policy while Newark runs $2,590, and a house on the Shore can cost three times as much to insure as a similar house inland.
New Jersey is the rare state where home insurance is cheap and car insurance is expensive, and the two facts come from the same map. The state is dense, wealthy, and heavily built up, which keeps rebuilding costs predictable and claims routine. It also sits on the Atlantic coast, where nor’easters and hurricanes hit, and a small share of homes near the water carry most of the risk. The figures below come from Insurify, NerdWallet, Insure.com, and MarketWatch, and where they disagree, the disagreement is shown rather than smoothed over.
How much does homeowners insurance cost in New Jersey?
Insurify puts the New Jersey average at $1,236 a year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage with a $1,000 deductible, based on rates updated November 17, 2026. NerdWallet puts it at $1,480 a year for $400,000 in dwelling coverage, from its May 6, 2026 analysis of median rates in every ZIP code. Insure.com puts it at $1,421 a year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage, from its analysis of more than 37 million quotes. MarketWatch puts it highest, at $1,991 a year, from five homeowner profiles priced through Quadrant Information Services.
The spread across studies comes from the sample homes, and NerdWallet shows the mechanism inside a single source. Its national table prices $400,000 in dwelling coverage at $1,480 a year, while its New Jersey state page prices $600,000 in dwelling coverage at $2,030 a year. The same source, the same state, a $550 a year difference, and the only change is the coverage level. Insurify’s March 2026 projection prices New Jersey at its typical dwelling coverage and projects $1,797 a year by the end of 2026, up 2 percent from $1,767 at the end of 2025. The honest range for a typical New Jersey house is roughly $1,200 to $2,000 a year, and the exact number is set by the coverage level first and the town second.
| Study | Dwelling coverage | Annual average | Monthly average | Updated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Insurify | $300,000 | $1,236 | $103 | November 17, 2026 |
| NerdWallet, national table | $400,000 | $1,480 | $123 | May 6, 2026 |
| Insure.com | $300,000 | $1,421 | $118 | 2026 |
| NerdWallet, New Jersey page | $600,000 | $2,030 | $169 | 2026 |
| MarketWatch | Five profiles | $1,991 | $166 | April 7, 2026 |
Coverage level moves the price more than almost anything else in New Jersey. The median rebuilding cost for a New Jersey home is $571,714, according to First Street, a climate risk modeling firm cited by NerdWallet. That is well above the $300,000 standard in the Insurify and Insure.com figures, which means many New Jersey homeowners need more dwelling coverage than the headline average prices. A homeowner who buys $300,000 in coverage for a house that costs $571,714 to rebuild is underinsured by nearly half, and the saving on the premium is not worth the gap after a total loss.
Which company has the cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey?
NJM, New Jersey Manufacturers, has the cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey. NerdWallet names NJM its best value choice at $1,570 a year for $600,000 in dwelling coverage, against a state average of $2,030 a year for the same coverage. MarketWatch names NJM the cheapest provider in the state at $88 a month, and its top pick overall for affordable premiums and wide availability. NJM is a local carrier that writes mainly in its home state, and its rates reflect a book of business built around New Jersey homes rather than a national average.
The local advantage is the story of this market. The national carriers price New Jersey as one state among fifty, while NJM prices it as the only state that matters. That shows up in the numbers: NJM at $1,570 a year for $600,000 in coverage runs 23 percent below the state average for the same policy. A homeowner who only quotes national carriers never sees that price, which is why the first quote in New Jersey should come from NJM, and the second and third from the national carriers for comparison.
Getting three quotes matters more in New Jersey than the low average suggests, because the spread between companies is wide. MarketWatch prices the state average at $166 a month while NJM sits at $88 a month, a $78 a month gap for comparable coverage. The gap is the largest single reason to compare companies in New Jersey rather than renewing on autopilot, and it is larger than the gap between most New Jersey cities.
What does home insurance cost in Atlantic City and Newark?
Atlantic City is the most expensive major city in New Jersey for homeowners insurance, and Newark sits in the middle. NerdWallet prices Atlantic City at $3,715 a year for $600,000 in dwelling coverage, against $2,590 a year in Newark for the same policy. That is a $1,125 a year gap for the same coverage, driven by coastal wind and flood exposure in Atlantic City rather than by the size of the city. The studies agree on the order: the further toward the Shore and the closer to the water, the higher the price.
The coastal premium is the catch behind the cheap statewide average. New Jersey ranks among the five cheapest states for home insurance, alongside Hawaii, Vermont, Delaware, and Alaska, all under $1,500 a year in the NerdWallet national table. That ranking describes the inland majority. A house in Atlantic City costs nearly three times the Insurify state average, and the difference is storm surge and flood exposure, not the house itself. Anyone buying near the Shore should get a quote before closing, because the premium can change the monthly cost of the house by hundreds of dollars.
| City | NerdWallet, $600,000 dwelling | What drives the price |
|---|---|---|
| Atlantic City | $3,715 a year | Coastal wind and storm surge exposure |
| Newark | $2,590 a year | Urban density, inland from the Shore |
| State average | $2,030 a year | Mix of inland and coastal homes |
The ZIP code view would show a wider range still, but the city averages are enough to make the point. A homeowner in Atlantic City pays about 83 percent more than the state average for the same coverage, while a homeowner in Newark pays about 28 percent more. The inland towns that pull the average down are the reason the state ranks so cheap, and they are also the reason the average misleads anyone buying on the coast.
What flood insurance adds on top
A standard New Jersey homeowners policy covers wind damage from a nor’easter or hurricane but does not cover flooding, and flooding is the risk that follows every major coastal storm in the state. Flood coverage needs a separate policy through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer. Our guide to flood insurance rates by ZIP code shows what the separate policy costs in different parts of the country, and our Community Rating System flood discount guide explains how towns that invest in flood mitigation earn discounts on NFIP premiums for their residents.
Homeowners in a Special Flood Hazard Area will usually find flood insurance required by the mortgage lender, but the risk is not limited to mapped zones. Heavy rain and storm surge reach homes outside the mapped areas, and a standard policy pays nothing for water that comes in from outside the house. The homeowners premium alone understates what a New Jersey homeowner near the water actually pays to be covered, and the flood premium belongs in the same budget as the homeowners premium. Our named-storm vs hurricane deductible explainer covers the separate wind deductible that applies to storm claims, and our 2026 homeowners insurance cost guide puts the New Jersey numbers next to the national picture.
What poor credit does to a New Jersey premium
Credit moves a New Jersey homeowners premium more than almost anything else. NerdWallet finds policyholders with poor credit paying an average of $3,655 a year for $600,000 in dwelling coverage, against $2,030 a year for homeowners with good credit. That is an 80 percent increase, or $1,625 more per year, for the same house and the same coverage. The penalty is larger than the gap between Atlantic City and Newark, and it applies to the whole state rather than to one town.
The credit penalty is worth knowing before shopping, because it changes which company to call first. Some carriers weight credit more heavily than others, and the cheapest company for a homeowner with good credit is not always the cheapest for a homeowner with poor credit. A homeowner whose credit has improved since the last renewal should ask for a re-rate, and a homeowner whose credit has slipped should get quotes from more companies rather than fewer. First-time buyers can start with our first-time buyer home insurance cost guide, and homeowners comparing the region can read our homeowners insurance in South Carolina guide, which uses the same datasets.
Frequently asked questions
How much is homeowners insurance in New Jersey?
Homeowners insurance in New Jersey costs $1,236 a year on average for $300,000 in dwelling coverage, according to Insurify data updated November 17, 2026. NerdWallet puts it at $1,480 a year for $400,000 in coverage and $2,030 a year for $600,000. A realistic range for a typical New Jersey house is roughly $1,200 to $2,000 a year, depending on the coverage level.
Which company has the cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey?
NJM, New Jersey Manufacturers, is cheapest. NerdWallet names NJM its best value choice at $1,570 a year for $600,000 in dwelling coverage, against a state average of $2,030 a year for the same coverage. MarketWatch names NJM the cheapest provider in the state at $88 a month. NJM is a local carrier that writes mainly in its home state.
Why is homeowners insurance so cheap in New Jersey?
New Jersey ranks among the five cheapest states for home insurance in the NerdWallet national table, all under $1,500 a year for $400,000 in dwelling coverage. The ranking describes the inland majority. Coastal homes cost far more: Atlantic City runs $3,715 a year for $600,000 in coverage, nearly three times the Insurify state average, because of storm surge and flood exposure.
Does New Jersey homeowners insurance cover flooding?
No. A standard homeowners policy covers wind damage from a nor’easter or hurricane but not flooding. Flood coverage needs a separate policy through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer. Homeowners in a Special Flood Hazard Area will usually find flood insurance required by the mortgage lender, and towns in FEMA’s Community Rating System earn discounts on NFIP premiums.
How much does poor credit add to home insurance in New Jersey?
Policyholders with poor credit pay an average of $3,655 a year for $600,000 in dwelling coverage in New Jersey, against $2,030 a year for homeowners with good credit, according to NerdWallet. That is an 80 percent increase, or $1,625 more per year, for the same house and the same coverage.
The short version: expect around $1,236 a year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage in New Jersey, per Insurify, with Atlantic City running $3,715 and Newark $2,590 for a $600,000 policy. NJM is cheapest at $1,570 a year for that larger policy, and the $78 a month gap between NJM and the state average is the reason to get three quotes. The two numbers that matter most after the premium are the dwelling coverage level, because the median New Jersey rebuild cost is $571,714, and whether flood coverage is in place, because the standard policy pays nothing for water that comes in from outside the house. NerdWallet’s New Jersey homeowners page and Insurify’s home insurance rates by state are the sources for the figures above.