On this page
Your homeowners insurance renewal arrives, and the number is higher than last year. Sometimes a little higher, sometimes a lot. Before you pay it or panic, run through this list. Most rate hikes can be reduced or explained away with an hour of work.
First, read the renewal notice carefully
Do not just look at the total. Check whether the dwelling coverage limit changed, whether the deductible changed, and whether any discounts disappeared. Coverage limits often rise automatically with inflation, which raises the premium even when the rate itself did not move. A missing discount, like a claims-free or new-home discount aging out, can explain a jump that looks mysterious.
Also check for errors. Is the square footage right? Is the construction type right? Is the roof age right? Mistakes on the application turn into overcharges every year until someone catches them. Compare the numbers against your declarations page and fix anything that is wrong before you shop.
Shop it, every time
This is the single most effective move. Get quotes from at least three to five insurers, with the same coverage limits and deductible on each quote so you are comparing real prices. Insurers price risk differently, and the cheapest carrier for your house this year may not be the one you are with.
If you are in a state where several carriers have pulled back, include an independent agent in your search. They can quote multiple companies at once and often know which carriers are still writing in your area. Our state-by-state rundown of the cheapest and most expensive states in 2026 explains why some markets are tougher than others.
Raise your deductible
The deductible is the part of a claim you pay yourself, and raising it is the fastest way to lower a premium. Moving from a $500 deductible to $2,500 can cut the premium substantially, because you are taking the small claims off the insurer’s books. Only do this if you can actually cover the higher deductible from savings. A deductible you cannot afford is not a saving.
Understand the two deductible types before you change yours: flat dollar deductibles and percentage deductibles, which are common for wind and hail in some states. We explain both in how home insurance deductibles work.
Ask for every discount
Insurers do not always apply discounts automatically. Call and ask about bundling with your auto policy, monitored security and fire alarms, new roof or system updates, claims-free history, and loyalty. Smart home devices in particular are an easy win: water leak sensors, monitored smoke detectors, and security systems all reduce expected claims. See our list of smart home devices that lower premiums and the broader discounts worth asking about.
Make the house cheaper to insure
Targeted updates lower both your risk and your premium. A new roof is the biggest one. Updated electrical and plumbing help, especially in older homes, and we covered the full picture in new vs old home insurance costs. Tell your insurer about the work and keep the documentation.
What not to do
Do not let the policy lapse out of frustration. If your mortgage requires insurance and you drop it, the lender will buy force-placed coverage for you at a much higher price with worse coverage. And do not slash your dwelling coverage limit to get the premium down. Underinsuring the house to save a few hundred dollars a year is a bad trade against a total loss. Understand why premiums rose in the first place, then shop and adjust from a position of knowledge.
