On this page
Your dental plan pays one price at an in-network dentist and a different, worse price everywhere else. The gap between those two prices is where surprise dental bills come from. Here is how the two networks actually work and what each one costs you.
What in-network means for your bill
An in-network dentist has a contract with your insurance company. The contract sets a negotiated fee for every procedure, and the dentist agrees to accept that fee as full payment. Your plan then pays its share of that negotiated fee, usually 100 percent for preventive, 70 to 80 percent for basic, and 50 percent for major work, and you pay the rest. Because the negotiated fee is lower than the dentist’s list price, both the plan’s payment and your share shrink.
The other protection in-network is balance billing, or rather the absence of it. The dentist cannot bill you for the difference between their list price and the negotiated fee. What you owe is the coinsurance on the allowed amount plus any unmet deductible, and that is it.
What happens out of network
Out of network, there is no contract and no negotiated fee. Most PPO plans still pay something, but they base it on “usual, customary, and reasonable” (UCR) fees, which the insurer sets using its own fee data. UCR figures tend to run conservative. The plan pays its percentage of the UCR amount, and you owe your coinsurance plus everything above the UCR fee. That gap is balance billing, and on major work it can add hundreds of dollars to your share.
DHMO plans are stricter: out-of-network care is generally not covered at all except in emergencies. If you have a DHMO and see an out-of-network dentist for a routine crown, expect to pay the full bill yourself.
A worked example
Say you need a crown. Your in-network dentist’s negotiated fee is $1,200. The plan covers major work at 50 percent, so it pays $600 and you pay $600 (after deductible). Now the out-of-network dentist down the street charges $1,800. Your plan’s UCR for a crown is $1,100, so it pays $550. You owe your $550 coinsurance plus the $700 difference between the $1,800 charge and the $1,100 UCR, for a total of $1,250. Same tooth, same plan, more than double the out-of-pocket cost.
How to check before you book
Use your carrier’s provider directory, not the dentist’s website, to confirm network status. Directories go stale, so call the number on your insurance card and ask specifically whether the dentist is in-network for your exact plan, since carriers run multiple networks. Ask the dental office for a predetermination: they send the treatment plan to the insurer and get back the exact covered amount. And if you are weighing whether to keep a beloved out-of-network dentist, run the full-year math the way our dental insurance versus paying out of pocket comparison does, because loyalty to one office can cost more than the premium difference between plans.
The bottom line
In-network means negotiated fees and no balance billing. Out of network means the plan pays a percentage of its own UCR number and you cover the rest, which can easily double your cost on major work. Before any big procedure, verify the dentist’s network status with your carrier and get the predetermination in writing. For the full picture of what plans pay for, see what dental insurance actually covers and whether dental insurance is worth it for your situation.
